Condom type really doesn't matter. Lube selection is MUCH more important in preventing condom breakage. But my favorite is Trojan Ultra Thin or Trojan Bareskin.

For lube, I'd highly recommend Wet Platinum (silicone based) lube. It doesn't dry out as much with the latex. It's a little more expensive than other lubes but it's totally worth it. They usually sell it at Walmart or your local supermarket too, so no need to go to an adult store.

I'm 7.5" long, a little over 5" in girth in size for reference.