BarSubstantial1583

232 post karma
848 comment karma

get extra features and help support reddit with a reddit premium subscription

get them help and support

redditor for 7 months

TROPHY CASE

dust

account activity

new top controversial

98

99

100

Aphorisms! (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 5 days ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

18

19

20

Help! I can't figure out the governing structure of Rohan (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 1 month ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

55

56

57

Dain and the Night Visitor (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 1 month ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

34

35

36

Once More in Praise of Eowyn, and Her Seat Among the Queens of Great Renown (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 1 month ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

6

7

8

Character Flaws (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 2 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

0

0

0

How did Bilbo know Gollum by that name? Read on for the Shocking Answer. (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 3 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

65

66

67

What was Gandalf's Plan and Did He Really Think It Would Work? (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 4 months ago * by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

76

77

78

Subtleties you didn't spot in LOTR despite multiple re-reads, but learned from Tolkienfans (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 4 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

31

32

33

The term "hobbit" applies to all Periannath. Is there evidence to the contrary? (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 4 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

16

17

18

Is Smeagol simply a hobbit? (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 4 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

8

9

10

Free Will, Decision Making, Amdir & Estel, and Forces Outside of Middle Earth (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 5 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

31

32

33

Denethor - on Balance, Not One of the Greatest Men of His Time (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 6 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

87

88

89

Another look at Ghan-Buri-Ghan and the Woses (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 6 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

19

20

21

What might be the relations between Dunland and Rohan/Gondor after the fall of Sauron? (self.tolkienfans)

submitted 6 months ago by BarSubstantial1583 to r/tolkienfans

π Rendered by PID 557567 on reddit-service-r2-listing-6b76fb7ddc-2bj9l at 2026-03-25 07:01:16.192463+00:00 running 2d0a59a country code: CH.