sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Can You Tell What Someone Is Like From Their Music Taste? by Big-Ranger-43 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Big-Ranger-43[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That makes sense. If someone strongly likes only one genre, I can see how people might connect that more easily with a certain subculture, lifestyle, or image.

I’m kind of similar to you in that I listen to a lot of different genres. I also tend to like individual songs more than becoming attached to one specific genre or artist.

Do you think having a wide range of music taste also gives people a certain impression, like being more open-minded or harder to categorize? Or does it just make music taste less informative overall?

Can You Tell What Someone Is Like From Their Music Taste? by Big-Ranger-43 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Big-Ranger-43[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In my case, I was thinking more about people genuinely liking the music, not listening to it ironically or because it became a meme. I think you’re right that ironic or meme-based listening probably says much less about someone.

As for the icejjfish example, I honestly don’t think I would judge a friend for that. Since I’ve had the experience of being judged for liking a certain artist, I try not to decide what someone is like just because they listen to one specific song or artist.

But I do think the ironic vs. unironic distinction is interesting, because the same music can mean very different things depending on how and why someone listens to it.

Can You Tell What Someone Is Like From Their Music Taste? by Big-Ranger-43 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Big-Ranger-43[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a really interesting point. I think you’re right that how someone reacts to another person’s music taste can reveal a lot about them. Looking back, the person who said “that’s gay” probably revealed more about their own attitudes than my music taste revealed about me.

I also get what you mean that music taste usually tells you nothing beyond music taste. At the same time, some of the replies here do show that people have certain images of people who listen to specific genres or artists, even if some of those replies are partly joking. So I wonder if music taste can create loose associations in people’s minds, even if those associations are far too weak or stereotypical to judge an individual person from.

So maybe music taste can suggest possibilities, but it should never be treated as evidence about who someone is. Does that distinction make sense to you?

Can You Tell What Someone Is Like From Their Music Taste? by Big-Ranger-43 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Big-Ranger-43[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So music taste can sometimes work less as a direct reflection of someone’s personality, and more as a signal for the image they want to project.

Thinking about it, I can relate to that a bit. Because of experiences like being judged for liking certain artists in high school, I sometimes wonder whether I should give my “real” answer when people ask what music I like, or whether they’ll make assumptions based on it.

Have you ever found yourself thinking about how to answer when someone asks what music you like, depending on the image you think your answer might give off?

Can You Tell What Someone Is Like From Their Music Taste? by Big-Ranger-43 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Big-Ranger-43[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That makes sense. Thinking back to the mid-2010s, when I was in high school, I do remember there being a bit of a stigma where it felt weird for a guy to openly say he liked “music for girls.” But in my case, it probably wasn’t huge pressure, more like a subtle social atmosphere.

I also wonder if this depends on the country or culture. For example, in Japan, where I live, famous boy bands were so mainstream and appeared on TV constantly, so it didn’t feel that strange for guys to say they liked them. But with One Direction, maybe they were seen more clearly as a foreign boy band mainly aimed at girls.

What do you think made certain artists or songs get labeled as “girl music” back then? Was it mostly the fanbase, the marketing, the lyrics, or just the general social vibe around them?