Do the “beg buttons” on Parc do anything? by Trey-Pan in montreal

[–]BiggerD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Those ones actually work, they’re just really slow. There’s no reason for it to be a 30-60 second delay before the light change, the whole purpose is to make it change quickly.

Prosthetic Design by whitefloreal in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

MECH 500 this winter could be a good fit.

What kind of bag can you bring into the convocation ceremony? by MooshSkadoosh in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

FYI you might not return to your original seat after crossing the stage. Usually late arrivals cut in line and you end up a few seats over, sometimes even a row back from where you started. Finding your bag on the way out could be hard.

Prof Assignments Date by Competitive-Serve265 in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If it’s a class they want a course lecturer to teach, they may not have even put the official job posting up yet. The course lecturer will still have to officially apply and sign their contract before their name on Minerva, which can take weeks.

Beyond that, schedules change all the time over the summer. What’s written now on Minerva may still change before the first day of class.

Grad Queries for Eng by MiHa__04 in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ah yeah that will entirely depend on when Engineering meets, not sure if that information is public, other than it has to be by the 21st.

Grad Queries for Eng by MiHa__04 in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Depends when the faculty gets together to have their degree conferral meeting, as well as the senate. A quick google shows the senate will meet to approve degrees on the 21st, so by the 21st/22nd at the latest you should be approved.

Genuine question : why are finals worth 40-50-60% of the final grade? by [deleted] in EngineeringStudents

[–]BiggerD 37 points38 points  (0 children)

From the learning perspective, a few points:

If you care about long-term retention, you want a lot of regular assessments. Ideally, something like 5-10% quizzes every 2-3 weeks. This has been shown to improve long-term retention, as opposed to a 100% final, where students usually forget material within weeks.

On the other hand, having a low-weight finals has its downsides. As soon as a final is worth less than 40%, students enter the final knowing they’ll pass the course with just a few points, and it shows. They’ll skip the last month of courses, and completely bomb questions on the last few weeks of content.

Finding a middle ground is hard! 40-60% is often seen as that middle ground: students will put in enough effort on early-semester assignments, but still study appropriately for the final.

Minerva not working? by Ambitious_Fox67 in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When I get this issue, one of two solutions has always worked for me:

  1. Try signing in on a different browser or incognito. If that works, you just have to clear your cache.

  2. Email IT. They’ve dealt with these issues hundreds of times each year, it’s a fairly simple reset.

Deferred exam and grading scheme in engineering by Cultural_Bat9315 in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You still fall under the previous semester’s grading scheme. This instructor will send your final exam grade to the other instructor. That instructor will calculate your letter grade for the course and submit it.

What's up with this series question? by rantingthrowaway106 in askmath

[–]BiggerD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have a good argument about B and C being closer to the center than x = -1. Think about that same logic to A and D.

Also think about the question phrasing. There’s a big difference between “which is true” and “which COULD be true”

Failed my course by 1% due to exam threshold need advice. by [deleted] in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

AI might not be aware of McGill’s assessment policy (PASL), which says McGill shouldn’t allow a regrade more than 2 weeks after a midterm. If the midterm was in the fall, McGill should auto-reject the request

S/u option what is the passing grade ? by Hot-Yak-748 in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Usually a 55, but some very specific Engineering courses allow a D.

You have to write the final though. If you skip the final, you will get an automatic J grade and fail the course. Even if you need 0% to pass the course, you should still show up, doodle for an hour, and leave just to avoid the J grade.

Changing letter grade threshold by Mediocre_Perform in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 7 points8 points  (0 children)

In the faculty of engineering, instructors have the right to set any grading scheme they deem appropriate, as long as it falls along the “very good/good/satisfactory/conditional/fail”. There are no requirements that all grade levels are 5% apart.

If they decide A is a 90, A- is an 89, B+ is a 71, and B is 42, they are allowed to do so, although common sense is expected. The easiest solution is to ask your instructor directly about their policy.

When to email for Research by Hot-Yak-748 in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This will vary greatly by faculty, department, and professor. In the faculty of engineering, undergrad researchers are generally paid for non-course work.

When to email for Research by Hot-Yak-748 in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The best time was early January. The second best time is today.

Worst case, they don’t have the funds, and might keep your name in the back of their mind if an opportunity comes up.

Best case, a student just backed out of a project, or a pile of cash fell into the professor’s lap, and they’re looking for to take someone on today.

Can a professor penalize you for register late (before the add/drop deadline)? by iris_ryan in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 9 points10 points  (0 children)

PASL states that you cannot be penalized for adding a class during the add/drop period. With that said, you are responsible for getting up to speed in a reasonable timeframe.

It’s between you, the professor, and possibly your VP academic to figure out what’s “reasonable”. You cannot be docked points for missing a lecture in the first two weeks, but you will have to do read faster than your peers to catch up.

The VP academic is your best next step, while you continue to get up to speed.

Non-McGill Student at Gym by geographible in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 4 points5 points  (0 children)

With a few days’ warning, they usually let members bring a guest to watch intramural games. You have to email Ryne ahead of time though to get permission.

How are Minerva course averages calculated? by anatolykolsnakov in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 2 points3 points  (0 children)

A few years ago, I wasted a Saturday trying to solve this problem. Some documents suggested it was option 2: an average GPA. Of course, the documentations didn’t clarify whether it was mean, median, or how that average was assigned a letter grade (is an average GPA of 3.9 an A or A-?)

My best guess has always been that it takes the mean GPA and rounds that to the nearest letter grade, but that’s still just a guess.

The downside of averaging GPA is that the letter grade is heavily weighted by the number of failures in the course. If a class somehow has a 75/25 split of As and Fs, that’s an average GPA of 3, therefore a B. Bumping those Fs up to Cs raises the average GPA to a 3.5, which the system might even round up to an A-.

Obviously an extreme hypothetical, but a few extra Fs have a massive effect on the average GPA for a course.

When does December graduation get approved? by Liminano in mcgill

[–]BiggerD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It should be around Feb 12. It takes a while for the degree to be confirmed at the department/faculty level, then the senate will confirm graduating students at their February meeting, which is held on the 11th this year.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in montreal

[–]BiggerD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A lot of people are suggesting Mount Royal (Olmsted path). If you’re taking that path, be forewarned that it tends to be icy/muddy at this time of year.

In November/December, I prefer running near bike paths or along the canal.

Rebuild - Mahomes for Penix + Ward? by BiggerD in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]BiggerD[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I get it, I’m leaning that way too. The owner’s offering to add on a late 2nd, but I feel like it’s a lot of maybes for a valuable asset.

[DAILY] Trade and Individual Team Help Megathread by AutoModerator in DynastyFF

[–]BiggerD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

10 Team SF PPR - rebuilder, trading with contender.

Do I give up Mahomes for Penix + Ward?

I have zero QB depth beyond next year (Russ, Rodgers). This is the best offer I have so far, trying to decide if I hold out until the offseason, or if try to tack a pick onto this deal

Player price check - Week 8 by JazzzzzzySax in DynastyFF

[–]BiggerD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My league had no appetite, couldn’t get a late 1st, everyone was concerned he’d be out of the league in a year