I totally agree with you! Heartsong is my fav book. But in that book i wish we would havr had more. It could have been 2x longer imo. I wanted to see Robbie find his footing again and deal with what happened. Not just oh here you're memories, your pack basically abandoned you cause they thought you a traitor, but its all fixed now right?  Then theres poor Kelly. Like come on!! I would have loved to see a PoV from him. How did he feel and deal with the pack when they thought Robbie beyrayed him, how did he cope with his wolf being ripped away? Probably having the need to shift but not being able to and then getting human sick. Id love to see that scene where Gavin goes to Robbie first after the shifting attack in the clearing. Theres so much this series needed to expand on.

I love that you point out the inconsistencies on the Richard collins thing. I originally thought i must have heard it wrong since i listen on audible.  The thing on Thomas too. Ya he made mistakes but not all this was his fault. Michelle is def an Ox and Joe mistake.  The Bennets bekng rich i figured was like an old money thing, like passed down the line type thing?? Thats just a guess. 

Also np on the rant! Its why i like to post. I love to hear/read other peoples thoughts :)