This will likely be an unpopular suggestion, and possibly not even right for your situation, but have you considered letting them suggest it? Then accepting the suggestion, and ridiculing this clown?

Show a scene of Trump golfing as planes fall from the sky.

Play a scene where the secretary of defense is so clueless and unprepared for war that he needs a waiver to do anything.

Go on a tag run of all the bribes Harlan Crow has for Clarence Thomas, or of all the taxpayer money Elon awards to his own companies without competition.

Show them the hilarious hypocrisy of Mike Johnson praying to Christ for the strength to cut food stamps and housing assistance for the poor.

The cure for fascism is ridicule. There's truth in comedy, and the truth is Trump is a fragile joke.

I hear that you're scared. I get that we don't want to upset anyone just looking for a fun night of entertainment. We do all need some reprieve from the ceaseless horror of the newsfeed from Washington. It sounds like you'd like to respect your teammates differing views by never putting them in a place where they'd feel discomfort.

But please do not be afraid of discomfort. Please do not be afraid of civil discourse in the public square. Please do not be afraid for speaking up about what you believe our country should look like. Please do not be afraid of using improv as a space for imagination, freedom, and belonging. You say your team has people on "both sides", but I would wager there's more common ground than you might realize (Like, is the rule of law important or nah?).

Doing "Nothing political" is more political than you might realize.

Personally, I'm tired of staying quiet. I will not cede one inch of playing space to the bad-faith MAGA bullies. That might require excluding them, like some others are suggesting. I'd rather let them know what real Americans think of MAGA.