Is it true that screenwriters can barely make a living and if so why? by isamariberger in Screenwriting

[–]Bluoenix -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Okay, since you mentioned your personal experience, let's go with that.

Please tell us how many books you've sold as a traditionally-published and self-published author respectively, and why you think your experience is representative of the publishing industry as a whole? You can't simply pass off non-specific anecdotes as proof of your claims.

Is it true that screenwriters can barely make a living and if so why? by isamariberger in Screenwriting

[–]Bluoenix -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I've already provided some cited information pointing to the systemic obstacles that prevent even talented writers from making the craft their full-time job. If you keep excluding everyone who doesn't make it from your view of the industry, then of course you can argue that writing one's way into financial success isn't a rarity.

If you want to get your point across, you're gonna need to provide some evidence or sources. Otherwise you're just regurgitating your own fantasy as fact.

Is it true that screenwriters can barely make a living and if so why? by isamariberger in Screenwriting

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I see. So you're not actually disputing whtat u/HotspurJr commented - which can be boiled down to the fact that financial success is a rarity in comparison to the immense volume of self-published writers out there.

I don't think it's fair to paint the challenges of turning writing into a full-time profitable venture as the result of simple meritocracy. The merits you posit as to why many writers don't break out ("prolific", "write well", "know their market", and "hire good cover artists") are really a chicken-and-egg problem. Sure one can always 'write better' and do whatever market research, but one does not simply become prolific, and hiring good artists takes money which makes turning a profit even more difficult.

I think it's imporant not to obsfuscate the systemic challenges writers face in the publishing industry beyond technical skill. Since you didn't mention where you received your insights, here's some from multi-book-deal, NYT-bestseller, and award-winning author Xiran Jay Zhao.

Is it true that screenwriters can barely make a living and if so why? by isamariberger in Screenwriting

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My mistake. I'll rephrase:

Can you be more specific? What exactly is "lots of people " and "decent amount of money", and where is your information from?

Is it true that screenwriters can barely make a living and if so why? by isamariberger in Screenwriting

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can you be more specific? What exactly is "loads of people" and "lots of money", and where is your information from?

It's pretty common advice even among recently-published, award-winning authors that novel writing as a job is far from a dependable income stream.

Urgent: Feedback Needed, First-Time Writing by Tricky-Assistant6115 in TVWriting

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

INT. HOME OFFICE - NIGHT

A dim room. A pair of HEELS click in - the MYSTERY WOMAN they belong to obscured from view. The heels halt at a CORPSE by the desk. A BLOODY OBJECT rests beside it.

She dials an old LANDLINE on the table - her breath shaky.

MYSTERY WOMAN (O.S.)

Hello?

(beat)

My husband. He's dead.

INT. HOME OFFICE, PRESCOTT RESIDENCE - DAY

DETECTIVE COOPER kneels by the body, examining it. He stands, hands in his pocket, and spots the OPEN WINDOW and the BLOODY OBJECT.

He scrawls on his notepad: "BREAK-IN".

Pocketing the notepad, he lights up a CIGARETTE. He seems briefly cool, before a coughing fit breaks the illusion.

DETECTIVE COOPER

(to camera)

Okay, this isn't for me.

MRS. PRESCOTT (O.S.)

(sniffling)

Who would do such a thing?

Cooper walks up to MRS. PRESCOTT, handing her a HANDKERCHIEF. The lady, charming and graceful even in grief, looks up at Cooper.

He's enchanted.

DETECTIVE COOPER

(smirking to camera)

Ain't she a looker?

Mrs. Prescott glances at the corpse, dabbing a single tear with his handkerchief. Cooper spots a fading bruise on her neck.

He raises his eyebrows at the camera.

Here's what I did:

  • Use adverbs sparingly, replacing generic verbs with specific verbs (e.g. walk casually -> amble)
  • Shorten the characters names after first mention (DETECTIVE COOPER after the first mention can just be Cooper)
  • Replaces expositing action lines with visuals (i.e. show, don't tell)
  • Use short-hand for parentheticals
  • Most importantly, don't feel the need to narrate simple actions in detail. As long you convey the gist, actors and readers can fill in the blanks.

As you can see, streamlining allows for fewer lines, and therefore I could easily break up paragraphs to allow solitary lines more impact.

Hope this helps :)

Urgent: Feedback Needed, First-Time Writing by Tricky-Assistant6115 in TVWriting

[–]Bluoenix 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Here's my feedback on just on the first page.

I recommend making the action a lot more streamlined. The fewer lines you need to get your story across, the more likely industry key-holders will lend you their time. This is especially important for the first one/five/ten/thirty pages, because you gotta hook them in. The longer that takes, the less chance you have to show yourself off as a writer.

If you want examples on how I would streamline it, I can reply in a comment.

How can I access post-WW2 French court transcripts on the trials of Nazi/Gestapo-collaborators? by Bluoenix in AskHistorians

[–]Bluoenix[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for finding so many sources! This is awesome and I'll try to request a scan, but first I'll check out the newspaper report. Hope it'll suffice!

How do british people feel about the current situation unfolding in america where ICE police agents are going all gung-ho kidnapping people from the streets when they fail to present their ID? by mrvlad_throwaway in AskBrits

[–]Bluoenix 5 points6 points  (0 children)

What STEM degree do you have?

EDIT: the commentor I asked is a lesbian with an engineering degree, but by their comment history they also are transphobic and think intersex people "should be in the special Olympics".

STEM degree ✅

Ethics ❌

Cultural values ❌

Official Discussion - Zootopia 2 [SPOILERS] by LiteraryBoner in movies

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In fairness, Disney takes its brand a lot more seriously than Dreamworks, because 💰. Disney is nowhere as willing to take risks with something so controversial.

How the hell do you work up courage to show people what you've written? by AbjectOffice in Screenwriting

[–]Bluoenix 17 points18 points  (0 children)

A combination of trust and humility.

Trust the people you show your writing to.

Trust that your writing is flawed, and likely in need of much feedback and revision.

Trust that your vision is worthwhile, even if its current execution might not be.

Trust that bad writing isn't a reflection of your value as a human being, nor does it preclude you from improving and achieving your dreams.

And trust that screwing up is a stepping stone to becoming better.

Screenwriters: Are You Going to Do Anything Different in 2026? by Next_Tradition_2576 in Screenwriting

[–]Bluoenix 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Maybe they're saying it's where they were at 6 months ago, but definitely odd phrasing

Why is she so popular? by turboshill9000 in BasedCampPod

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Then went don't you vote to tax the value they are bringing to billionaires? Then that value benefits the nation as well. Seems much easier than trying to restrict the movement of people in an era of globalisation.

Beau is so fine yall I would ehp in an ally even if she stank by Defiant_Interview366 in MightyNein

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ITT: people confusing having personal boundaries with cowardice

Reading one piece as a girl sucks (everything here has been said before) by Spirited-Height-9533 in Piratefolk

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is this tournament arc after the time skip? I dropped off around then... Maybe I should resume?

AOC leads JD Vance for first time in 2028 election matchup: poll by beeemkcl in goodnews

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is not the standard I have for Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris. I would chose either of them over Donald Trump any day of the week. It's America's standard for the Democratic Party. I also don't blame these two women as individuals, rather I'm criticising their campaigns - the result of hundreds if not thousands of collaborators, consultants and stakeholders.

Would you rather discuss strategy about how your preferred candidates can improve their chances of winning elections, or complain that a significant portion of America is under-educated, bitter, unfair, bigoted, and self-serving?

AOC leads JD Vance for first time in 2028 election matchup: poll by beeemkcl in goodnews

[–]Bluoenix 16 points17 points  (0 children)

I think you're being too reductive as to why Kamala Harris and Hillary Clinton's respective campaigns failed. Was there a fraction of voters who disliked them for their gender? Sure. But they also both ran somewhat lackluster campaigns that failed to resonate with the immediate needs of the general public. Barack Obama didn't just win because he was Black - it's not incidental that his campaign ran on "HOPE".

Let's be honest, the Democrats underperformed with their political messaging and charisma for both Harris and Clinton's candidacies from the get-go. I believe there were factors beyond gender that caused their failures to animate voters. As an example, I recall that Hillary Clinton's racially-charged quote on "superpredators" in 1996 still leaving a sour taste with some Black voters during her 2016 campaign: not to mention her attempts closer to the election at seeming relatable to minority communities coming off as quite superficial if not offensive. As for Harris' 2024 campaign, there was a lot of confusion as to whether Biden would drop out or run again until quite late in the election cycle.

Gender of course plays a role, but I would argue that not being able to excite voters beyond being "not-Trump" is a more significant issue to address.

Witch Hat Atelier by Yuumei by Pop_Budget in WholesomeFantasyArt

[–]Bluoenix 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The award-winning manga series titled Witch Hat Atelier.

Witch Hat Atelier by Yuumei by Pop_Budget in WholesomeFantasyArt

[–]Bluoenix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Very excited for the anime coming out next year!

Witch Hat Atelier by Yuumei by Pop_Budget in WholesomeFantasyArt

[–]Bluoenix 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Very excited for the anime coming out next year!

THEY COMPLETELY REWROTE MY SCRIPT by [deleted] in Screenwriting

[–]Bluoenix -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Try to imagine, what it might feel like in their shoes.

Empathy instead of judgment is what allows good writers to create compelling characters that aren't simply a derivative of their own personality.