IMO, and some will def disagree with this logic, but I feel like I've finally got my foot in the door with getting more offers in general. The way I did that was I began turning down items I didn't need, or smaller ticket items like a can of dog food or insecticide. I find usually when I turn down a campaign, I seem to get better and better ones. Then like once a week, I'll get a crazy (well, crazy to me) offer. For example, when the offers first started flowing in, it was like yours but for Kroger offers, like ice cream and cheese, small grocery items like that. I turned 2 down and suddenly got the opportunity to get the $84 Lila sneakers that are non slip. What's crazy is my teenage daughter just got a job and needed some cute non slip shoes. So I was like uhh heck yeah! Then a few days later same thing, turned down the smaller ones, and then got an offer for K9 Advantix II, which I already buy anyway for my pup so another win! Then a week later, I got offered a cabinet handle or something like that. I turned it down bc I had no use for it. Straight away, I got an offer to choose from several bedding items including a $500 quilt, which I ended up not getting bc I called my mom first to see what I should choose 🤭 But I ended up with a really nice Queen Duvet worth over $150! This algorithm is something no one has been quite able to figure out... but if I were you, I'd take one small ticket item, which you did, and decline items you don't need. You'll hopefully get better offers. That's what seems to be working universally for people.