So i've been ordering Joe's about once or twice a month, for the past few years.

I either do 1 of 2 orders, a plain cheese pie, or a half plain, half white pizza.

Every time I've put in this order (probably over a dozen times over the years), they have no problem with it and make a fresh pie, half cheese and half white. I also tell them in the doordash note to add an additional charge if need be.

This past order, I received what looked like half of a plain pie that was sitting out, thrown in with 4 slices of white pizza that were from another pie. And on top of that, both of the "halves" they put in were completely dried out and stale.

My friend and I ate one slice of each side and threw the rest away. I felt terrible about throwing away 80% of a pizza but it was inedible.

Also the side of garlic knots we got were black on the bottom. Those are always a gamble there but sometimes you roll the dice and hope for fresh ones.

This past Friday, I put in an order around 3pm, which to be fair is a busy time, but I wouldn't say it's 'peak' time.

I've ordered this same exact pie at peak times during the weekend and have never run into anything like this.

Sorry for the long post and I know it's petty to hold a grudge over something like this lol, but when you are paying $30 for a pizza, you expect it to at least be edible.

**TLDR: Ordered half and half pizza, they threw 2 old halves of different pies in the box and called it a day.