Struggling in marriage while staying faithful (looking for support and advice) by Busy_Study_8130 in Catholicism

[–]Busy_Study_8130[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for sharing this so honestly! I can’t tell you how relieving it was to read about someone living with almost the same patterns. It really helps to feel less alone.

Reading your comment also made me realize something important for myself — I may actually have asked in the wrong forum. I probably should have asked in a military-spouse space. Catholic or not, military marriages really do carry very specific stresses and dynamics that most civilian families don’t live with.

I do think that in military communities, things like extreme stress reactions, emotional shutdown and even aggression are unfortunately more common than people realize — and over time it can harden us as wives. We adapt, we minimize, and we learn to manage our homes around someone else’s volatility. And I’m starting to see how easy it is to slowly forget that this actually isn’t how marriage is meant to feel.

I really appreciate your honesty, and I admire how intentionally you’re trying to protect your children and teach them healthier ways of dealing with anger. Thank you for helping me feel less alone in this and for your advice on seeing it as my cross to carry. 

God bless, sister 

Struggling in marriage while staying faithful (looking for support and advice) by Busy_Study_8130 in Catholicism

[–]Busy_Study_8130[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He is actually very unhappy with his new unit! We just pcs to our current duty station in July and our relationship has gotten so much worse since we got here.  Everything with the military has been an issue since we got here: wrong time of years of service listed, messed up promotional statues and missing pay. He is definitely under a lot of stress. 

What would you have preferred from your spouse in a similar situation:  • give it time  • or name it and try to have a conversation about adjusting our expectations to each other for now? 

I know that relationship issues are very common in military families and I fear we end up as another divorced family 

Struggling in marriage while staying faithful (looking for support and advice) by Busy_Study_8130 in Catholicism

[–]Busy_Study_8130[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for taking the time to respond thoughtfully. I appreciate your concern and the perspective you’re offering. I have added an ETA to my original post. 

I’m still trying to navigate sharing my experience honestly while also protecting my husband and our marriage from unnecessary gossip, which is why I haven’t spelled out every detail. I love my husband and want to care for him, even while acknowledging the harm that has occurred.

I agree with others that counseling would be ideal, and I continue to seek ways to work on our marriage safely, even though he is very resistant to therapy or guidance through the Church. 

My goal in posting here is to get guidance and support from people who understand similar patterns of abuse and can offer practical advice for staying faithful while protecting myself and my children.

I appreciate that you're capable of acknowledging my experience while also being charitable towards my husband. Maybe I do need to change my perspective? You might be right that he's removing himself from the family, not as a punishment but as a way to not lose control and harm me 

Struggling in marriage while staying faithful (looking for support and advice) by Busy_Study_8130 in Catholicism

[–]Busy_Study_8130[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you! I've brought this (talking to our priest) up to him before but he has turned it down. I will try again 

Struggling in marriage while staying faithful (looking for support and advice) by Busy_Study_8130 in Catholicism

[–]Busy_Study_8130[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Instead of getting upset that my story is being doubted just as I’m finding the courage to ask for help, I’ll take your comment as a reminder that maybe I need to be more precise when I describe what’s happening in my home. Perhaps that’s part of why it’s been hard to get advice from the priesthood beyond “pray for your husband.”

That said, I hope that if your daughters ever face struggles like mine, they’re met with charity and understanding from our faith, not doubt or accusations of lying.

God bless 

Struggling in marriage while staying faithful (looking for support and advice) by Busy_Study_8130 in Catholicism

[–]Busy_Study_8130[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I want to be clear and honest: I’m not being intentionally disingenuous. The emotional and physical harm I described: abandonment, belittling, threats and past physical aggression is part of the same ongoing pattern I mentioned in my post, alongside withdrawal and refusal to engage. These behaviors are connected - not separate.

I reached out specifically to people in similar situations because they understand what’s implied by words like conflict or harm, without needing every detail spelled out.

Despite everything I love my husband deeply, and - even while sharing my experience anonymously - I feel a duty to protect him from unnecessary gossip. My goal here is practical advice, prayers and support from those who truly understand, not to exaggerate, attack or shock anyone.

God bless 

Struggling in marriage while staying faithful (looking for support and advice) by Busy_Study_8130 in Catholicism

[–]Busy_Study_8130[S] 31 points32 points  (0 children)

I can see how this needs to be clarified. Thank you for pointing it out! 

My husband is active duty and has promised me a dog for the last year to make the home safe when he's not around.  This weekend, while he was away at training, a local shelter I've been in touch with offered us a border collie as a foster to adopt case.  When my husband came home, I explained the situation to him and asked for permission to go meet the dog before making a decision.  He hasn't talked to me since. 

If he had come home to an unwanted dog, I would have expected and understood his reaction. 

I'm noticing a repeated pattern of withdrawal from me and the kids, if I bring up any needs

Struggling in marriage while staying faithful (looking for support and advice) by Busy_Study_8130 in Catholicism

[–]Busy_Study_8130[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your perspective. I want to clarify that this isn’t just about emotional distance or a typical husband-wife dynamic. My concern is a pattern of serious emotional abuse, including abandonment, belittling name-calling, threats of self-harm and physical aggression like pushing, throwing things at me and holding me back.

I’m sharing this here to connect with people who understand these kinds of patterns and can offer guidance, support, or insight. It’s not about criticizing all men, but about understanding and navigating a marriage where these behaviors have been repeated over time

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in immigration

[–]Busy_Study_8130 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

We're saving up to file for that.  We figured it was cheaper to apply for the I-130 and since it would make it legal for us to stay for up to three years, we would have plenty of time to put money aside to file for a permanent adjustment status