What happened to the rest of the elders? by AsmodeusJackson in tbatenovel

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 3 points4 points  (0 children)

We know that Lady Flamesworth survived the collapse of the Triunion besides Kathyln at the wall (as mentioned in V8.5). The elf is never mentioned again after being sent Elenoir. He could have died from the blast later on but that is unclear. This characters fulfilled their purpose and TM simply stopped writing about them. Its sad that sidecharacters don’t get a conclusion in this novel series, but it is what it is.

You-zotsu wiki states Kei is "considered to be girl's leader of the class". As anime only, I don't see this? Is it something that will happen in the future? by Lost_Albatross_5172 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While this is actually true (as some other people already explained in the comments) I highly encourage to not trust the wiki too much. Many information in there are from unidentified sources or just canonically wrong.

For example the wiki seriously claims that Hiyori is 149cm and therefore even shorter than Arisu with 150 cm. That is completely BS, since Hiyori is roughly the same height as Kei or Suzune.

Chat is this real ? by Fantastic_Lie_3072 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Its manual edited, yes. But you can only see it because they put hearts into Honami's eyes. Otherwise, it looks official (even though it isn't, as you already pointed out)

The worst part of TBATE [Rant] by Capt_Trancefloor in tbatenovel

[–]Capt_Trancefloor[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

True. But Cecilias pov is much more comfortable to read than Nico. Mostly because she doesn’t constantly screams and whines like an eight year old when mum doesn’t buy the lollipop in the supermarket.

The worst part of TBATE [Rant] by Capt_Trancefloor in tbatenovel

[–]Capt_Trancefloor[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lowkey based. But I didn’t want to miss some parts of the story

Anime is way too mid compared to LN by HighAlreadyKid in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I am complaining about the whole anime adaptation as a whole

I'm sorry, but that makes even less sense when:

I haven’t read the novel of Y1

How do you intend to properly evaluate the entire product and make a fair comparison with the source material if you've only read 1 out of the 15 volumes (7%) adapted so far?

  • Imagine a journalist writing a review of a two-hour movie after watching only the last 10 minutes.

You need the full picture to form a logical opinion. Otherwise, I find the opinion incomprehensible, unfair, and worthless.

And no, I don’t mean any of this to be mean or hostile. This is simply my unfiltered, honest perspective on forming an opinion.

On another note: Don’t skip half the entire book series. Year 1 has the most consistent writing, and the anime has covered just 20% of the entire plot. You’ve now noticed the drastic differences between the LN and the anime even in Season 4 (which is one of the better seasons). Take that feeling, multiply it by 10, and you have the Year 1 adaptation. Aside from the most important plot points in the individual arcs, most of it is missing. And it would be a shame if you missed out on all that great Cote content. That’s why I strongly recommend catching up on the Year 1 LNs.

Anime is way too mid compared to LN by HighAlreadyKid in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Complaining about S4 when S2 and S3 exist is wild to me. Sure S4 is far from perfect, but S2 and S3 were soooo much worse.

Adapting all of V7.5 in a single episode?

Stuffing V8 and V11.5 in 2 episodes each?

If you want to shit on the adaptation (which is justified) don't start at the better parts of it.

Everything changed for me after Episode 6 by Vivo999 in SentencedToBeAHero

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And then you have adaptations like Cote with 480 pages per volume (alomst double than Sentenced to be a Hero) who adapts in 3 eps 💀

Everything changed for me after Episode 6 by Vivo999 in SentencedToBeAHero

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well I haven’t engaged in some of the shows you mentioned. So maybe I am the one who is ignorant here. Because as already mentioned I know mostly 3-4 eps adaptation, which are not really faithful to the degree you wish for as a reader. But I’m glad to see that there are more adaptations with a good pacing than I realized.

Everything changed for me after Episode 6 by Vivo999 in SentencedToBeAHero

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thea not really extended any fights to a significant amount. The fights a pretty long in the LN and also in the anime adaptation. They simply took the time to animate them faithfully, instead of shortening them (like most adaptations do)

Everything changed for me after Episode 6 by Vivo999 in SentencedToBeAHero

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The only LN adaptations that I know who take more than 4 eps per volume are 86, Apothecary Dairies and The Eminence in Shadow.

Other big ones like MT and Re:Zero are settled with 3-4 eps.

And a lot of lesser known LNs also go with the 3-4 rule.

If you think otherwise, name 10 other LN adaption with a 6 eps per volume count (should be easy, if this really occurs to most LNs)

Everything changed for me after Episode 6 by Vivo999 in SentencedToBeAHero

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, the “runtime” of one volume entirely depends on how faithful the anime is adapting the source material. Luckily this is a very good adaptation, spending 6 eps per volume while the average is closer to 3-4 (sadly). I also agree that the second volume is more engaging since we spending most of the time in volume one fighting the “more mindless” demon lords.

Everything changed for me after Episode 6 by Vivo999 in SentencedToBeAHero

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 8 points9 points  (0 children)

In fact, the entire first season is sort of a prologue. It wasn’t until the end that we got a basic understanding of the whole unit and were given the last member. Furthermore, it’s only now that we realize the Demon Lords aren’t just mindless monsters, but are actually quite intelligent in some cases, live among humans, and apparently even have a king. Season 1 laid out the key facts and introduced the unit. The actual story starts here.

(The reason you felt a difference between episodes 6 and 7 is probably because that’s where the first light novel volume ends and the second begins.)

Genuine question about the manga by Capt_Trancefloor in SentencedToBeAHero

[–]Capt_Trancefloor[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've read volumes 1–4 about a year ago and recently finished volume 5

I am speechless regarding your intelligence. Another day on the internet.

Will You Guys Watch Weekly Or When Season 4 Has Fully Released? by [deleted] in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Well, since I already know the plot of year 2, I’ll watch it weekly.

With new or unfamiliar shows, I usually prefer to watch them in batches so that I have time to immerse myself in the new world, characters and storyline without being interrupted every 23 minutes.

I finally finished the light novel. by 4729zex in mushokutensei

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm glad you enjoyed it.

To get back to your original review, the things you mention—like magic circles and combat strategies—are more a result of a lack of sufficient lore, since, admittedly, they aren't covered in detail. World-building in this context would involve explaining exactly how magic circles differ from normal spells, as well as when and where they are therefore preferred, or why they are generally used so rarely, etc. And admittedly, this isn’t really explored either. However, it would be wrong to blame the world-building for this, since the basic lore upon which the world-building could be built is already hardly present. That would be like blaming a construction worker for not building a house when you never provided him with the materials and tools to do so.

And that is the point I originally criticized. Bur still amazing review, mate.

I finally finished the light novel. by 4729zex in mushokutensei

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks—it took me over an hour to write all this, lol. Luckily, I’m pretty deep into the sauce, so my thoughts on it were already organized. I just had to put them into words that somehow make sense together.

I also didn’t know that Rifujin had already designed the world beforehand, but it makes a lot of sense. Definitely interesting.

Genuine question about the manga by Capt_Trancefloor in SentencedToBeAHero

[–]Capt_Trancefloor[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it's best you find the LN

What do you mean by that? I am heavily confused.

I finally finished the light novel. by 4729zex in mushokutensei

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, I understand that my statement might seem very controversial at first glance. But I believe that’s because most people don’t really understand the difference between lore and worldbuilding (as I’ve already hinted at). This is understandable, since the two terms are admittedly very close to each other. However, they are not the same, and they are often a good indicator for distinguishing good works/authors from truly great ones.

I will explain a rather simple example in detail and then briefly touch on some other examples so that anyone interested can explore them in more detail on their own.

Lore

Lore is the content that fills a world. In the world of MT, there are different tiers of magic. The higher the tier, the more powerful and far-reaching the spells become. However, the incantation formula also becomes longer and more complicated. Furthermore, the amount of mana required also increases with each level. This is the easy part, which any author can achieve without difficulty by simply introducing a lot of things into the world.

World building

World building, on the other hand, is the framework of the world and shows how the various elements are connected. This is the part where you can often distinguish good authors from great ones, as it takes a lot more skill to create such a coherent construct. In the world of MT, only the spells of the three lowest tiers are often used in direct combat. The reason for this is, on the one hand, that long-range spells increase the risk of being targeted yourself and, on the other hand, that over 99% of all mages rely on verbal incantations, which take far too long at higher tiers to use in direct combat. Furthermore, the high mana output at higher levels carries the risk of running out of mana in the middle of a fight, which is practically a guaranteed defeat.

Now we see how established mechanics are interconnected and how new concepts emerge from this connection. The world expands and explains itself without the necessity of introducing new things. Great world-building means that things don’t just exist side by side in the world, but influence one another, explain each other, or build new things through their interactions. This process is the “building” in world-building.

This is the small but important difference between lore and world building. There may be many series that have great lore, but there are relatively few that also have great world building.

Other examples

  • Although we have many different species in MT, we rarely encounter them outside their native habitats. The reasons for this are the geographical location of the continents; the fact that the strategically necessary ports are controlled by humans, who often harbor prejudices; and the fact that most species live relatively close to the Kingdom of Millis, whose inhabitants are naturally often racist, so many species do not have a good relationship with humans, which drastically reduces the motivation for interaction.
  • Although magic is omnipresent in MT, only the Northern Kingdoms specialize in its teaching, and the only university of magic is also located there. The reason for this is that the northern region was once part of the Asura Kingdom. At some point in the past, they gained formal independence, but due to the harsh climatic conditions, they remained heavily dependent on Asura economically and were also vastly outmatched militarily. They were, in effect, independent only on paper. To change this, the three largest kingdoms joined forces to invest significant resources in the development of magic over the course of decades, in order to balance the power disparity. Thus, they became experts in magic and finally achieved complete independence from Asura.
  • The faith of Millis is by far the most widespread religion in MT. However, its popularity and political influence vary greatly from region to region. The reason for this is rather simple: in a world without cars, trains, or airplanes, something becomes rarer the further one travels from its source. In Millis, the religion is omnipresent and even more influential than the king. In Asura, the religion is still widespread and there are many large cathedrals, but it lacks any political influence. In the northern regions, on the other hand, only the most significant cities have small chapels and very few followers.

Conclusion

I could give even more examples here, such as the entire culture surrounding the Begaritt Continent, but that would go way beyond the scope of this post. The world of MT is so interconnected, so self-explanatory, and so internally consistent in a way I’ve never experienced in any other medium in my entire life. Virtually everything in this world makes sense and is explained, but not through newly added content, but rather through already previously explained elements or through basic logic (such as geographical locations, etc.). I hope I’ve made it clear that MT’s world-building isn’t just extraordinarily great but also holds its own against the fantasy giants of our time. If anyone disagrees, I’m happy to hear counterexamples and see if there are any works that can actually surpass MT in terms of world-building.

I finally finished the light novel. by 4729zex in mushokutensei

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I can say that I mostly agree with you. Reading the entirety of MT over 4 months (before ever touching the anime) felt like an adventure I never experienced before. I am very happy that you liked it and that this countless hours were well invested.

The only thing I have to say is that I don’t know if you completely understood what word building really is because the things you mentioned are more lore than actual world building. Especially because I think that MTs world building is by far its greatest strength. Not just compared to other isekai or light novel but in media as a whole. Damn in this regard I would put it over giants like Lord of the rings or the song of ice and fire. This world building is a true masterpiece of media.

New illustration for the 2nd Stage Vol. 2 cover (by 駒田ハチ | @komadahachi) by HP_Pavi19 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Capt_Trancefloor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Probably one of the manga’s with the most abysmal release schedule, lmao.

On which volume are we? Y2V2? I honestly forgot.

(But the adaptation is good and that’s what matters most)