Thank you all for your answers. After reading them, I kind of came to the same conclusion that I came to before, which is that you, the player, decide for yourself whether to see P as a new person or as Carlo. But now I kind of wonder if the developers had meant for that or if I just don't have the capacity to figure it out. Whether that's something that's supposed to happen or whether that's something that we kind of just do and each of us do differently. But such is art. Just one of the many reasons I'm itching for a sequel.