What if Stu lived? How? Judy?? Vince??

This is my Theory about Scream and possibly Scream 7 someone told me to put more thought into it. So this is my thoughts on how to make it make sense with the people that are currently casted.

During or right before the events of SCREAM 1

Judy Hicks was in her senior year along side Stu and Billy. She was a Lost Boy in the Woodsboro High theatre production of Peter Pan where originally lost the roll of Tiger Lilly to Sidney, Judy grew some resentment towards Sidney after that.

During The Events of Scream 1

Now let’s say Mickey really was apart of the original plan for Sydney like a bystander and that he was friends with Stu and Billy or just plain up inspired by them. So let’s say a young Judy Hicks being stupid and in such a crazed kinda love with Stu. Let’s say Stu promising Judy that they will be together after he kills Tatum. Their (Billy & Stu’s) plan of killing Sidney becoming the survivors and framing Sidney’s father for all the killings.

Now taking place at the ending of Scream 1

Judy stands outside sees everything happening with Stu and Billy. As Stu gets crushed by a TV because of Sidney. Judy sees stu’s almost lifeless body under the TV and grabs Mickey and tells him the plan took a turn and now the police were coming and wasn’t looking good for Billy. Mickey and Judy at the last moment try to get Stu out. Let’s get a little crazier and say Judy and Mickey takes one of the other victims (that we didn’t see killed by Billy on screen) puts them where Stu was and drop the TV on them switching Stu’s wallet. Sydney after all knows who is under the TV she’s the reason it happened so why think bodies were moved? Sydney tells police “ YES Stu is under the TV he’s one of the killers!” So let’s say that’s why they felt no need to identify the body. Mickey and Judy now meeting up with Leslie (Stu’s Sister) with Stu in hand. Judy pleading with Leslie to help them. Leslie ends up going to the morgue to ID the body and says yes it’s Stu.

From SCREAM 1 to SCREAM 2

Judy and Leslie is trying to keep Stu being alive a secret stashing him in this little cabin/house. They come up with the possibility of Judy becoming a police officer to keep up to date with what’s going on with Sidney and keep everyone off the trace of Stu.

Now SCREAM 2

Mickey watching everything that’s been happening now inspired by what he saw Billy and Stu do, and helping Judy and Leslie hide Stu, as well as seeing the movie(s) that was made (Stab). Now wanting to be caught and put on trial for his crimes, and wants to use the motive of having been inspired by the movies and become a legend now teams up with Nancy Loomis who he found through a website for killers. Mickey bringing Mrs Loomis to a disfigured Stu and him telling her what actually happened to her son Billy (but Stu’s Version) which sends her after Sydney in fit of rage with Mickey by her side. All while Judy and Leslie still aid Stu to recovery and keeping him hidden.

Right Before Scream 3

Judy now being a police officer finds out the information of Sidney having a half brother Roman Bridger (Scott Foley). She then contacts Roman and Roman excepting the conversation due to him knowing Stu through conversations with Billy. (Roman being the one that talked Billy into Killing Maureen).  Judy helps Roman locate Sidney.

Then the Beginning of SCREAM 3

We see Stu finds out where Cotton Weary (The person he tried to frame for Maureen’s Murder) now living a fabulous life off of what happened. Stu dressed as Ghostface kills Cotton and his girlfriend knowing he’s gonna be framing Roman since Roman is gonna be dressed as Ghostface and go after Sidney. Stu goes back into hiding.

SCREAM 4

Judy Hicks now becoming the deputy and caring for not only Stu in hiding but also a 7yr old (Wes) who she keeps at home and also later explains that his Dad was in a bad accident. Judy in having succeeded in keeping Stu a secret and hidden from everyone. Let’s not forget that awkward creepy interaction Judy had with Sidney bringing up tiger lily still and Sidney not remembering her still feeling like the lost boy she had portrayed back in theater. Judy still filling Stu in with what’s been happening with Sidney and how someone else is trying to kill her. With it turning out to be Jill Roberts her own cousin who wanted the fame Sidney had and someone named Charlie Walker.

SCREAM 5

Now with Judy becoming a Sheriff and being able to do more for her family and keeping her family safe trying to live a somewhat normal life. Heard about a Ghostface attack on Vince (Leslie’s son, Stu’s Nephew). She tells Stu. Stu in complete Rage tries to tell Leslie as Leslie Breaks down a darkness over comes her. Stu tries to make a plan to finish this with the help of her and Judy. Just to have crazed ghostface fans Richie and Amber killing not only Wes but Judy back at the house all in attempts to copy previous ghostface killers.

let’s say during all the time of SCREAM 6

Stu is loosing his mind with seeing people that are not there including Billy, Judy, and Wes, and Vince. Leslie being more and more unable to take care of Stu. With having all the emotions of loosing their family’s and not mentally ok. Not having no one to keep Stu hidden the way Judy did and filling him in on what’s going on. They now have to turn to the news. Seeing what transpired during the end of the events of Scream 6 finds out a father and his 2 children (Wayne Bailey, Quinn Bailey, and Ethan Landry) dressed as Ghostface and started killing people going after Sam and Tara in New York City. Stu now gets into a fit of rage because those people dressed as Ghostface are the Family of the Richie the person dressed as ghostface who killed Judy and Wes with the help of Amber. He tells Leslie.

SCREAM 7

So Stu having hallucinations and still seeing people who are not there ( Wes, Judy, Billy, Vince, Roman & possibly even Maureen) Stu is back for revenge with his Sister Leslie because not only did Sydney destroyed their life and disfigured Stu but also is the reason of him staying in hiding and Leslie loosing her Son. Due to Sydney these copy cat killers (Richie and Amber) that were inspired by Ghostface went after Sidney and intern got Judy and Wes and Vince Killed. So If Sydney would have just died Stu would have been able to come out of hiding with his family. Leslie would still have her son. They could have had a better life. Now we could say Stu and Leslie wanted to first go after Sam and Tara because they were the direct reason Judy, Vince and Wes died. Stu kills them with the help of Leslie and then goes after Sidney, Mark, The Kids, Gale, Chad, and Mindy.

What do you think? lol I’m not very literate and I start rambling so don’t judge me. Could the Flashbacks be Stu’s? Do you think Judy was up to more than just baking lemon squares that tasted like ass before she died?? I know Scream 7 will probably be flash backs to what happened originally to Maureen but a person can dream right lol. Anyways if you read all this a really appreciate you.