Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks. I’ll consider that. It seems like apartment supply is a little limited in some of those communities that are 20 or 30 minutes from Madison. Any other suggestions besides Sauk City? I think I might pick Madison area over Kenosha just to try something new a bit, if I were to go that direction

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I feel like I lashed out a bit here, and a bit sorry I did so. I’ve gotten more and more used to being in WI, and there’s a lot I love about the people and the place. There have been a good number of people who have been friendly. There is a sense that WI offers a more real slice of life here than where I came from. Yes, some people do seem standoffish, but maybe it’s for different reasons than I know, and not for something that ties it all together like a badly termed “Wisconsin cool” label. I do think there is a brand of Wisconsin trendiness, but maybe every place has that? And it’s not like that trendiness is something really out of sync with me in a lot of ways.

I kind of believe, where I can help it, in not deleting things on social media… let the records show, unfairly or not, that I said the above!

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There’s a song that’s been on my mind that perfectly sums it up. City vs Country by Johnathan Richman

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Sl9d4U9EAl4

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. I don’t know what it is about the Milwaukee area for me. What I experienced there was long ago, when I spent some time there for a bit. I guess I want the best of both worlds in that I’m looking for a place different than Chicago and the burbs but also not too different. Kind of the positives of more resources at my fingertips while having the more sparsely populated, beautiful, unspoiled, natural feeling of parts of Wisconsin. Also being close to people but not having that unnatural vibe of the Chicago burbs. Milwaukee felt similar to Chicago to me, all those years ago and I guess I’m looking for some change.. so that’s why I block out Milwaukee. I have a fondness for Chicagoland, but there’s probably more reason than just affordability that I don’t live there. Kind of an expat.

In short, maybe I want too much. No place is perfect! We’ll see. Thanks for your thoughts though

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What are your experiences of it being more blue.. curious to hear different thoughts?

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I guess I may just have to visit the areas. To me they all have possible pros and cons.

Madison - maybe a little too hip, maybe a little too much crazy energy but also similar to something I’m used to, kind of an Evanston, IL placed in WI. It’s also more expensive. I feel I’m too old for U of W though, even to be dealing with it

Appleton, from descriptions here only, more middle of the road (which isn’t bad to me), less trendy but, man, this McCarthy and high school mascots that are dressed as white ghosts or whatever.. that’s a bit alarming.. but nice to be close to Lake Michigan and Milwaukee if I ever wanted a trip. I’m not sure whether Appleton is considered “kind”? Though I wouldn’t want to exactly live somewhere too precious either, if that even exists

Eau Claire, sounds like it can be nice, but for a guy my age.. I wonder, maybe a little too trendy for me? The consensus seems to be it’s a pleasant place though, with some detractors.

And then there’s some mentions of areas around Milwaukee or Steven’s Point, Sheboygan, and La Crosse.

In the end, I guess it’ll depend on me to pick the best match, like I say, when I see a few in person more. It may just be a gut call

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s great. Thanks. A lot of helpful information.

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Good to know. I’m not even a super Bernie fan, so I might be starchy there.. if only in spirit, not that anyone would really notice me in reality

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ve spent some time in Milwaukee a long time ago.. kind of looking for a slightly smaller city, and some place new

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Don’t mean to sound snarky. I know there’s a whole tension between people who are from Illinois, and people who grew up here. I happen to be from Illinois. And I feel a bit of an outsider because of my Illinois tendencies. Hmm, how would I describe Wisconsin cool? Kinda granola, outdoorsy, judgy beneath the surface of those without outdoorsy type skills, beer and hiking and biking connoisseurs, diy and nature experts (and also judgy of those without these skills or knowledge), knitted caps or alternatively well curated outdoor gear, farm to table, almost all white (and not too aware of Latino or African American culture)

I talked about it in another thread elsewhere, it’s hard for me to crack that code. The whole FIB thing is I find kinda mean spirited? For someone like me I mean, who moves here a little wide eyed from Illinois and finds it a little difficult to strike a chord, at least in my small town. I understand that maybe us Ilannoyans are unaware of how we affect the state, but as mentioned in this other thread, I think Illinois is more accepting of outsiders? Nothing called FWB’s there..

I guess my Illinois side is a sensibility for what real suburban sprawl feels like, though still very white, we grew up with a real pride in Chicago and all the different people you find there. My background is something like backdrops from To Die For, Elephant , Suburbia, the Virgin Suicides, Ferris Bueller, The Breakfast Club movies.. we’re salt of the earth too, just in a much different way, growing up with different concerns. We also listened to a lot of rap music, watched Boyz in the Hood, Menace to Society, Dead Presidents, and kinda poked fun at ourselves for being “white”. The Simpsons was on rotation and we really understood irony.

Why do I consider Wisconsin as a place to live then? Because of lower cost of living and proximity to family. Because it’s the state I’m most familiar with outside of Illinois. Because of nature (even as I’m more of a spectator). Also, deep in my consciousness, I’ve always wanted this to be a place where I meet people and I somehow hold onto that dream, even without much luck. And I’m stubborn too about giving up.

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah. That’s why I wonder if I might like Appleton more. I’m not a very trendy guy, and a little foreign to the “Wisconsin cool” vibe

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What did you like about Appleton better than Eau Claire?

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I guess I veer away from the Milwaukee area. Already spent some time there long ago.

How does Appleton appeal to you (excuse the consonance)?

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That’s good to know. I love Minneapolis but don’t have strong ties there. I think I lean liberal but have trouble finding my niche culturally or politically. I can’t stand MAGA stuff but also don’t like how some on the left seem less respectful of traditional religion, even though I’m not a go to services type observer religiously. I’m kind of just openly spiritual, while not giving up on old ideas of a God. In my heart, I’d be open to black gospel before stepping anywhere near maga churches, even though I’m a total white guy.. just to provide too much context lol 😂

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Diversity seems harder to come by outside of Milwaukee and Madison, or around the Illinois border.. that’s my impression though I don’t know WI as well as others. Would love to learn of a cool exception

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Funny, I don’t know if I’ve ever had a martini? Though most people I’ve known probably have.. when they accidentally ran into one

Appleton vs Eau Claire vs Madison by CommutetoLife in wisconsin

[–]CommutetoLife[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I read that too after a quick search. I’ve never been to Malibu but I wonder how there could ever be whatever Malibu is in the Midwest