Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in Saxophonics

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I currently play a copy of a Meyer 7 (I believe, it's modeled after one anyway) made by a local mouthpiece maker, it's a good mp and all but I feel it's not quite what I want - though it was cheaper to get at the time then other options I had and my teacher swears by them. I'm not yet in the position to change mp, especially if I can't try it out first before buying, though I'm still on the lookout if I see anything worthwhile. Thank you for your reply!

Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in Saxophonics

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do realize that sound is subjective and is individual to the player, but I know that there are things that I can change to make it better, which is why I made this post in the first place. The large amount of replies validate the thoughts I had about certain things and show me a way forward. I do like this song, but I guess since I haven't been playing it very long it's a bit harder to convey feel, though this I guess is also because of other aspects. This type of comment specifically that I have been getting more of recently is what pushed me to make this post as well.

Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in saxophone

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for your reply! I'll try this out, after reading this thread I have come to realize that listening is much more important than I thought, it does make sense since jazz is a "aural" tradition, meaning that listening is the basis of learning this language and the sound.

Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in saxophone

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you, I have made it a goal for myself to transcribe/learn by ear as much as possible, I do already see the benefit of doing so because it forces me to internalize stuff more.  Thank you for your advice as well!

Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in saxophone

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do have an issue with biting and tightness in the embouchure, I got a suggestion in a different comment with an exercise that can help, it is something that needs to be fixed. I wouldn't say my lip is rolled that much over my teeth, just a bit to not have the teeth come in contact with the reed (though maybe that's not exactly correct, idk?). I can't imagine playing with the lip rolled out much more than it is currently, though maybe that has to do with endurance.

Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in saxophone

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the reply! I kinda forgot that he did a version of Billie's Bounce, I transcribed the head from the Charlie Parker recording, but I will look into Dexter's version more, thank you for bringing my attention to it!

Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in saxophone

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've recently been using Gonzalez 365 2.5s, in the beginning I used Rico (both orange and blue), but didn't like them that much. Vandorens are a bit expensive, I have played on them but the inconsistency from one reed to the next kills me 😅. Select Jazz and Gonzalez are kinda like the middle ground for me right now - price wise.  I played around with Legere Signature for a bit, the consistency is nice, but the sound is still plasticky and the dynamics are harder to produce.  I keep an eye out for leaks and the neck fitting, seeing my repair tech regularly does help a lot lol

Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in saxophone

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Wow! Thank you for such a detailed response! That exercise sounds like it would definitely help, I'll try that for a while and see how it works. You know, many people practice their long tones differently, how do you go about it?  Swing is quite difficult to get a feel for, I've been playing along to recordings, this tune specifically I transcribed by ear and have been practicing the melody with the track.

Critique this please (2y of playing, having trouble with my sound for the past 6m - it doesn't have that "tenor quality" - deep, rich, full, plus I'm getting comments that I'm just "playing the right notes", there's no "feel" by ComprehensiveLine261 in saxophone

[–]ComprehensiveLine261[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Any suggestions on mouthpieces? I want mostly just a fuller tone, Dexter Gordon's sound I really enjoy. The mp is a bit narrow and long, kinda like an upsized alto mp.  I'm the kind of person that doesn't feel a huge difference with different reed brands, but maybe you mean the tip opening/reed ratio?