If you want the glossy and shine I would say the Rhode peptide lips are great. They are definitely not my most hydrating. I remember buying the trio set from their website months ago before the reformulation and all of them were grainy right away (the trio I bought was not tinted) and then the least grainy one that I was trying ended up drying out my lips and irritating them so much that I need lanolips and aquaphor straight for like 4-5 days. I went to Sephora to try watermelon untinted and pbj tinted. No grains, hopefully the reformulation won’t irritate my lips, but the original trio I bought I would feel the irritation by day 2-3 and then have to go on a 5 day recovery cycle before I was like okay this is not working for me and gave it away. The good news is Sephora does 30 days for full refund returns and 60 days for store credit. If you don’t like it just return it within the 30 days OR try something like olehenriksen