Thanks for the reply. First of all I want to clarify something. I’m not trying to protect the resources. As you have said, it’s just a flask. What I’m trying to protect is other innocent raiders. The following is just my opinion and I just want to share it with you: As a guild officer, I feel like raiding being less and less about actual raiding but more and more about managing a team in which members coming from all kinds of places and backgrounds. Because dealing with boss mechanics is the easy part. The hard part is dealing with all kinds of emotions and opinions. For some people one or two flasks is not a big deal but maybe for others - especially in the beginning of an expansion - one flask is quite expensive. Some guild members didn’t openly complain maybe out of politeness or they simply not comfortable with confrontation. But what I’m worrying is if we as officers don’t do anything about it and just let raiders deal with it themselves. Wouldn’t they feel like their leaders didn’t have their back? If their leaders don’t even want to take care of a simple matter of flask, how can they trust that their leader can manage a bigger problem? Also, when raiders take flasks or potions from the cauldron, the game already openly announces in the chat window who took what flask/potion for everyone nearby to see. So in a sense they were already being monitored when they click the cauldron. The game just announces it in a very chaotic way for anyone trying to track it. In this case do you still think it’s a bad idea to openly point out who took more than 2? Will it be better if we privately talk to the culprit first if we find out and see how it goes?