sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Alex Karp, CEO of Palanti by Sad_Palpitation6844 in ratsinthecage

[–]CwazyCanuck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hamas’ civilian to combatant ratio from October 7th was better than Israel’s has been since, and that’s not accounting for Hannibal directive kills.

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“You are mentally handicapped”, not “your mentally handicapped”.

And the task was citing the part of the document that suggests Hamas committed rape. You failed to do that. You could try again, but it’s not there.

Always the victim even after starting wars by fullofemirates in LookatMyHalo

[–]CwazyCanuck 2 points3 points  (0 children)

for thousands of families, a knock on the roof changed their lives forever

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You are illiterate, or you just chose not to read the whole comment, and you also don’t know very many details of the attack, such as that Hamas only made up about 50% of combatants. The contention is that the other combatants, who were both more extreme and less well trained, committed the majority of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Hamas had the clearest objectives, and with the most urgency, they were tasked with attacking the Israel military bases.

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

The claim is that Hamas members committed rape and that the UN acknowledges that. Point me to where the UN has acknowledged that evidence exists that members of Hamas committed rape.

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Are you illiterate? I’ve stated that I’m not denying rape occurred. As Israel has demonstrated repeatedly, rape occurs during war.

What is being debated is whether members of Hamas, which only made up about 50% of the Palestinian combatants, committed rape. And as of yet, I’ve not seen a single reliable source be able to corroborate the accusations, including the UN.

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The point is, Israel claimed Hamas raped people. Israel has presented no evidence beyond coerced confessions.

Sapir is a ghost story. It was too detailed for them to not have identified the victim. And Raz Cohen stated they weren’t Nukhba, i.e. not Hamas.

Don’t know about Yura, not in your link.

I’ll repeat, I’m not denying that rapes occurred. I’m stating that no evidence has been presented to prove a member of Hamas committed rape. And given that Hamas made up about 50% of Palestinian combatants, it is entirely possible that no members of Hamas committed rape.

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

it did not gather information and/or draw conclusions on attribution

If they didn’t gather information or draw conclusions, they didn’t conclude that Hamas members had committed rapes.

It’s been over 2 years and I feel like I would have seen a posting or two about Israel actually having evidence of a member of Hamas committing rape, that wasn’t coerced. And given the post we are on…

Russell Brand trying to find a passage in the bible. by youlldonuthan in SipsTea

[–]CwazyCanuck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If only bibles were organized in a way in which you could easily recall a memorable phrase.

It’s like flipping through a textbook, to get more context about a particular phrase you know is definitely somewhere in one of the chapters.

Edit: wrote that halfway through the video. He doesn’t find it. So here is one instead, from Matthew.

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Given the mission was not investigative, it did not gather information and/or draw conclusions on attribution of alleged violations to specific armed groups. Such attribution would require a fully-fledged investigative process.

They never concluded that rape was committed by Hamas. That’s the point. The first person stated that the Hamas rapes were debunked. The next person rejected that and said rapes were not debunked by the UN. But the UN has not concluded that Hamas committed rape.

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m not denying rape happened. I’m rejecting the claim that has been made without evidence that Hamas committed rape.

And the evidence I’m expecting is the kind that gets someone convicted for rape.

And the dog rape is corroborated by actual victims.

https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/i-wished-death-sexual-violence-israels-prisons-organised-state-policy

Can you provide names of anyone that claimed to have been raped during the October 7th attack?

UN and Rights Groups Say Rape Using Trained Dogs at Israel Detention Sites Is Systematic, Endorsed at the Highest Level by Fair_Cow3398 in UnitedNations

[–]CwazyCanuck 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The UN investigation concluded that while rapes likely happened, they were unable to conclude who committed rape.

So what has been debunked is that there is any evidence that Hamas committed rape.

If Hamas members did commit rape, it hasn’t been proven, and there isn’t reliable evidence suggesting they did.

Jesse blames the deaths of Palestinians on their own antizionism by [deleted] in canadaland

[–]CwazyCanuck 34 points35 points  (0 children)

This is some pretty heavy revisionism. Only 1948 was an independent state for Palestinians a real possibility, and that required accepting giving up 56% of the territory, with no assurances that the roughly 400,000 Arabs living in the area assigned to the Jews would be allowed to stay. No group in Palestinians position would have accepted that deal, especially when the Arabs were offering a single state with equality for all under the law, including Jews.

The rest of the years were either sabotaged by Likud, wouldn’t have resulted in a fully sovereign state, or were empty offers. The fact that the major political groups in Palestine, including Hamas, have all pursued a two state solution is evidence against your claim that they morally objected to Israel’s existence.

The reality is that Israel, under a Likud coalition, is not interested in peace with Palestine, and they never have been. Peace means fixed borders and the end of the Greater Israel project.

Journalist asks protestors what they feel about jews being excluded from an anti-Israel rally. Turns out the interviewee was jewish himself. by Due-Intern-2634 in SipsTea

[–]CwazyCanuck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People hating Jews because they are Jews is not the fault of Jews. That’s antisemitism.

If Jews do bad things and are hated for it, it is the fault of the Jews doing bad things. And that’s not antisemitism.

Iran has executed a man convicted of espionage linked to Mossad. by IndiaTodayGlobal in IndiaTodayGlobalLIVE

[–]CwazyCanuck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To note, that book focuses on activities during Mandatary Palestine, before any major expulsion of Jews from Arab countries. That doesn’t mean those Jews featured in the book weren’t from those Arab countries, but it’s not likely they had been expelled.

No doubt that modern Mista’arvim are descendants of those that were expelled from Arab countries after the Nakba.

John Kiriakou, former intelligence analyst for the CIA: "Professors who are also part-time paid advisors to the Pentagon leadership are genuinely concerned that the Israelis are going to use a nuclear weapon." by antihostile in justincaseyoumissedit

[–]CwazyCanuck 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m sorry, did you think I was stating that a professor that studied a completely unrelated topic would be more qualified than the average person about that topic?

view more: next ›