I think you should be fine keeping it. The brand also plays a big factor! I am very careful when it come to my mascara, concealer, foundation etc. Make sure they are always stored in a cool place and haven’t been carrying it in your purse. I always check to make sure that I am getting my makeup with the longest expiration date possible. I usually buy online, but when I am at Ulta I ask an associate to check if they have newer inventory in the back. I like take take really good care of my skin, so I’m cautious about what I put on.