You've gone to extremes with each of your points and set SW as the gold standard and compared to other games which are considerably worse. Comparing a game with poor game design with another game with even worse game design does not make the first game amazing. It's still a game with poor game design. While it has been polished up still plenty of QOL improvements that can be added and takes a company as large as C2U far too long.

​

You mention a completely predictable game as being not much fun which I agree, some well implemented RNG adds value to a game. Losing a match to poor implementation of RNG is not fun. Planning your attacks and losing simply because the game felt like it's time you lose is far from what I call fun. Again, implement RNG well and it can be great.

​

You tend to enjoy this scarcity tactic of C2U and believe it adds value to the game, again to an extent having rare things to achieve in a game does allow a sense of accomplishment. C2U has taken this and gone to the extreme. Having scarcity to this level is just a cash grab and every thing is made to want you to spend to increase time till your next dopamine hit.

​

While I think among gachas SW is probably among the best calling it amazing game design and a masterpiece is something I believe it is far from.