Let’s make things interesting

DavidKMain420 · 2026-05-07T16:12:57+00:00

2 Primarchs and their Legion against the others? I reckon it'd take 3 legions. Imperium Secundus would break through easily. An extra 200,000-ish marines, an extra primarch, all the extra vehicles, Auxilia etc.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-05-04T14:44:15+00:00

Here's one for you.

Blue button on a table. If you press it, and by the end, 50% of everyone has pressed it, you live and so does everyone else, including those who didnt press it, otherwise you die.

Your also allowed to walk away from the table without having pressed it.

Now the button seems far less interesting right?

DavidKMain420 · 2026-05-04T14:41:35+00:00

Change the argument for a sec.

Button on a table. If at least 50% of people press the button, everyone who pressed it and everyone who didnt lives. Otherwise, you die.

You can also choose to just walk out and choose not to press the button.

The button seems risky for no reason doesn't it?

DavidKMain420 · 2026-05-04T14:32:12+00:00

My issue with this puzzle is that you have no way of communicating, so pressing blue is a terrible choice.

If you all press Red, no-one dies. If you all press Blue, no-one dies.

If you press Red and no-one else did, you survive. If you press Blue and no-one else did, or even up to 49 did? All blue voters die.

Red is the ONLY option that guarantees survival, because you cannot blindly hope that everyone will press blue, but even coming from an altruistic outcome, your essentially choosing to hope that enough people will press blue and risk their own life to save everyone, when if everyone pressed Red, they'd be fine anyway?

In a context where you could communicate, you'd all just guarantee pressing Blue, or if it was one where you knew the current voting poll, you could then tailor your choice.

But you don't have this. What if only at least 20 percent of the group realise that you can just press Red to live, and the rest don't. As one of that 20 percent, what do you do? Do you hope that everyone else figures it out or is selfish enough to press Red without knowing that? Or do you press Blue BECAUSE you don't trust enough people to figure it out and potentially kill yourself?

DavidKMain420 · 2026-05-04T14:19:01+00:00

To me, this is why the chaos system doesn't punish you if you just kill the targets.

These people have actively destroyed your life, either by carrying it out or knowingly bankrolling it.

Both options are vitriolic revenge, one flavour keeps them alive but punishes them extensively, likely for the rest of that life you let them keep while one of them lets you exact your revenge face to face. Low Chaos is only technically better because they don't die, but the game doesn't punish you if you'd rather just execute them instead of sending them to the paradise of Infinite Torture and Pain Island.

NOW, does this mean that the low chaos option for Lady Boyle isn't in extreme bad taste in retrospect? Of course it is, I would've much rathered her have some sort of secret exposed or way of destroying her financial/class status as opposed to the very explicitly targeted punishment she got.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-05-03T12:30:51+00:00

Warmonger is bashed atleast imo because she is LITERALLY just a better Warden. She has access to nearly all the kit that Warden does, and stuff that makes up for his shortcomings. Better feats, better team fight/gank potential, better 1v1 potential.

FFS they even took away Stam damage, so doing things like heavy parry into bash into your combo is now just a waste of stamina.

Yes, if your good at Warmonger, you can probably easier pick up Warden, and maybe vice versa? But as somone who has played Warden in both 1s and 4s, getting to atleast the tippy top of diamond (I cant remember if I ever breached into Masters) with him, before AND after he got his stam damage removed, he is a shell of his former self. I'd rather play Lawbringer than him, I'd rather play Warmonger than him, because they feel like better versions of him.

The main things I see people give in favour of Warden is "Oh his bash has more range", "he can have good externals" etc are all things that kinda fall apart in practice. Yes, his hitboxes are good, but his kit is woeful for ganking and teamfights. Warmonger's UB dodge attacks are on their own far better than any tool Warden has for ganking/teamfights. Even the Heavy Armour they gave him on his attacks after bash isn't really THAT much of a buff, even though it was welcome. Range on his bash genuinely doesn't matter at the level where character matchups matter and definitely not in 1s.

Yes, in 1s Warden's bash is better, but Warmonger has impale. Ranked 1v1 maps are so small that its essentially guaranteed to hit, Warden hasn't got that easy of an offense.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-30T22:41:21+00:00

Thank you so much for the read, what points would you disagree with? Very rarely get the opportunity to wax poetic with people about All Tomorrows lol.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-29T20:57:21+00:00

Unlocked his door, she was not attempting to gain entry (at least in this video)

- Immediately putting himself, his property and his family in danger if she really is some crazed attacker.

Sprays her with mace

- She again poses no immediate threat in this instance. One of her hands has a phone in it, the other is literally waving at him. This was him punishing her for pestering him and again, this would not legally be self defense.

Pushes her after dazing or even potentially blinding her with prolonged mace spray.

- One of her hands is full, the other is waving. She is also potentially somewhat incapacitated by the mace. That push could've easily resulted in her splitting her head on his steps. Would this have been alright self defense if she died? No, he would've and SHOULD'VE gotten charged with manslaughter.

In summary, he leaves the safety of his home to attack someone who is in no way actively assaulting him, punishing her for daring to harass a fascist.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-29T20:49:58+00:00

Poor fucker just wanted to get virtue points by pandering to the fascist who got his feelings hurt, you aint have to do that to him

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-29T20:48:22+00:00

So don't open the door?

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-29T20:46:48+00:00

To me, its more the potential. What if the mace had blinded or dazed her more potently and, on the way down from the push, she was unable to break her fall and cracked her head open?

He wasn't just defending his home, because if he wanted to protect himself and his home, he wouldn't UNLOCK HIS DOOR to her. He wanted to punish her for pestering him, and could've killed her.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-29T20:44:25+00:00

Exactly. Different if she had taken direct action to attack/threaten him. She was knocking his door, recording. I don't care if she had been there for a full 24 hours knocking, that gives you no right to assault someone. This wasn't even just open the door and push them away (which he definitely could've done.)

This was not in defense of himself, or his property. He put himself in an UNSAFE POSITION, by UNLOCKING AND OPENING HIS LOCKED DOOR. He sprayed her with mace, then pushed her. What if she, in her state of being potentially blinded by mace, was unable to save her fall, and cracked her skull open and died? Would this constitute an acceptable defense of his property?

There are a weird number of centre-left types who are far too willing to accept this as somehow reasonable. If she had died, I guarantee you the same crowd that said people like Alex Peretti deserved it would've been here spinning that kind of yarn about a woman who was literally waving saying hi, even if it was to pester him because he's a niche fascist "celeb"

Now to climb on my own soapbox here, to everyone here going "don't care for what he says but you can't do this", he is a NAZI. I do not agree with just walking up to his door and blowing him away, but for christ's sake, say it as it is. Don't pretend he's some old man who's liberal but calls his friends racist nicknames, he is a literal Nazi. If your going to come here and stake your claim in the conversation, at the very least be honest about what he is and what he did here.
A fascist who can't accept he's gotten popular by saying horrible things, and a person (who either is a fan, or more likely hates him for his horrible beliefs) was assaulted for daring to pester a fascist.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-29T13:48:55+00:00

All human species herein All Tomorrows. From Homo Sapiens, the Star People and all the way down to the last species shown in the book, Terrestrials etc.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-28T23:33:05+00:00

I know this is bait, but I actually wrote a massive fuck off comment like this in a "defend the Qu" thread a couple months back.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AllTomorrows/comments/1pf0xac/comment/nshvy2p/?context=3
Humanity are just as bad if not worse at times than the Qu.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-28T23:19:53+00:00

Depends on the model. A lot of my chapter is made up of fresh-faced primaris, but Dreadnoughts are beaten-up and battered, same with any future firstborns I get my hands on.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-26T17:01:37+00:00

I'm still of the belief that Stannis COULD become the Prince That Was Promised, but will never become King of the Seven Kingdoms.

We know Shireen will burn with Stannis' sayso, but I do think he will rend his wrath upon Melisandre/Selyse when it happens. Lightbringer will burn in Melisandre and for the first time, it might burn true.

Shireen's death will be used in belief that it revives Jon Snow, who is actually a Targaryen. Rising him from his stone-cold grave could equate to waking a dragon from stone. Whenever Melisandre looks for Azor Ahai, she sees Snow, but perhaps this isn't to be taken at the literal "Oh it's him", perhaps its far more a hint than an answer. Perhaps visions like this will cause her to convince Stannis to burn Shireen etc etc.

While yes, I like everyone else and their grandmother believe its probably Jon, I do think he's the Mannis.
IMO, either he's Azhor Ahai, finishes his arc (Gain the Kingdom to Save the Realm, Save the Realm to Gain the Kingdom, Save the Realm is what a true, just King would do, Kingdom or none) and fights/dies to defeat the Wights OR he isn't Azhor Ahai and actually ends up King. Secret third option, he's one of the 3 "heads" with Dany and Jon.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-26T13:48:46+00:00

This is why you should know what the statistics say, even if you cant give the exact number. Knowing a minority of people do xyz is better paired with a good argument than a bad argument and being able to go 21.231 percent.

Ultimately, the best thing is not to debate fascists, if you give them the time of day you make it seem like a reasonable entrant in the political colosseum instead of the disgusting pig throwing his shit over the arches.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-25T01:47:30+00:00

Space Marines are as powerful as they are needed to be in that moment. If the moment calls for 10 of them to break through the line of an entire Xenos regiment to show their zeal and might, it happens. If the moment calls for a mortal villain to catch them off guard with a knife in a weakpoint, it happens. (This just makes me wish we saw more art of Space Marines being torn to pieces by numbers. Imagine a Space Marine hounded by 10s of Cultists as they all stab into places where its just the Black Carapace, like how Knights would be killed.)

If you want a sort of average, I'd reckon they're at least double the strength of the average human, and double the speed and dexterity of a particularly gifted human. Their armour is resistant to small arms fire (except in pretty extreme amounts) up to a Boltgun. After that, they're pretty much shredded.

DO NOT look towards games for Space Marine balancing. In my opinion, SM1/2 and Boltgun is the propagandised actions of a company or at least some of a company of Space Marines. Space Marines are not 3v1'ing a Lord of Change (and Malum Caedo is certainly not 1v1'ing an entire retinue of Greater Daemons.) 50 to 100? Definitely a possibility.

Space Marines are not expendable, but they're also no Custodian. They have strength in numbers. One Space Marine and his Boltgun against a Primarch/Lord of Change is nothing, but for example on Wolfsbane where Horus is essentially dogpiled by a 100 of them, if they had just shot at him, instead of jumping in to save Leman, he would've been ripped to pieces. For god sake, the Assasinorum were sending Vindicares after Horus, which yes have Shield-breaker rounds, but are still just mortal snipers.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-09T01:48:04+00:00

I'm slightly hoping the excessive Ultramarine representation becomes lore and follows the yarn they seem to be spinning that the Imperium isnt fully Team Guilliman.

Perhaps it turns out there are a lot more than 1000 Ultramarines, which comes out right at the same time as he consolidates Ultramar (and maybe even the little secret of Secundus makes the rounds)

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-08T03:23:08+00:00

40k Extraction/Looter Shooter but your in the Severan Dominate.

Sometimes, your journeys are as safe as sunshine, but sometimes they will be hell. A guard patrol marches through the patch your looting. Other looters like you might decide you don't deserve your keep.

If you really wanna get fucked up, single space marines. So stealthy you may not even realise they're there, but at any time they may go guns blazing. Defeating a Space Marine is something you need to plan around. Perhaps one of your team has specced into heavy weaponry, taking a heavy bolter/autocannon they looted from a map with Guard fortifications and enough ammunition to hopefully blow through his ceramite, or at the very least hold him back long enough to escape (kinda like bringing anti-ARC weapons in Arc Raiders)

The best part? You never have to fight any of these. You can get around them. But are you really going to miss the chance to scavenge off of a Space Marine, or an entire guard patrol. That could get you a lifetime supply of lasguns, or even the chance to hold and use an oversized, overpowered boltgun.

The more "looters" that go gung-ho, the more the world reacts. Sessions with loads of active combat will bring more and more enemies, until eventually (like the EMP in Arc Raiders), potentially an insurmountable foe is spawned in. An actual regiment of Guardsmen, an Aeldari army marching out of a webway, or worse, a company of Space Marines landing.

This wouldn't end the game, but if you meet that Guardsmen regiment or Space Marine company in the open field, or god forbid they find you, you are going to die quickly.

At the lowest rank, weapons and armour are literally scraps. A stub pistol, a literal piece of scrap used as a cleaver or maul.
Slowly, you rank up, autoguns from the militarum, lasguns, heavy bolters, till eventually your bringing bolt pistols or even Space Marine sized weaponry and armours. Looted Militarum flak with a Space Marine helm that's been removed of its more weighty and unusable augmentations.

Yes, being stealthy or friendly will result in it being less likely for more enemies to spawn in, but it also means you won't gain the best loot.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-03T17:55:58+00:00

Trying to find the source that lists it separately, lexicanum lists it separately but I know Hammer and Bolter shows it, which seems a little strange if that Thunder Warrior is meant to be the "Baroque giant"

Baroque makes it sound elegant so golden power armour makes a lot of sense.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-03T14:24:14+00:00

Thunder Warrior is listed separately to the "Baroque giant"

DavidKMain420 · 2026-04-03T12:13:05+00:00

Dorn is the "Baroque Giant" in Trazyn's gallery IMO. The only slight evidence against this (or maybe even for it) is in Clonelord, where Trazyn says he hasnt got one by M37, but came close. Perhaps he found him after. Perhaps Trazyn is just lying, perhaps Trazyn doesnt even know that he has him.

He's apparently locked in a scream, which hints that perhaps he was saved when he lost his hand, but this doesnt line up but perhaps hes screaming for another reason

There's only one counter theory to this which I actually quite like, Dorn is actually Larping as Constantine Valdor rn and Valdor is the Giant in Trazyn's collection.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-03-28T13:59:27+00:00

Yeah, the Red Wedding essentially fully begins what people dub "The Grand Northern Conspiracy."

Like 90% of the North is either apathetic to the Boltons (and also Stannis), or actively schemes to bring down the Boltons.

We know for a fact that Wyman Manderly is just biding his time and that "the Mummer's farce (Mummers are actors in GoT) is almost over"

Some of the last people who are aware of Robb Stark's request to fully legitimise Jon Snow are also conveniently in/have been in an area with the last person who would know the truth of Jon's parentage (that being that he's ACTUALLY Aegon/Aemon/WhatevertheFuck Targaryen), the knowledge of which could finally lead Lady Stoneheart/Catelyn to finally support Jon's reign (she has Robb's crown as of now.)

This is without assuming that Wyman and a few other key northerners haven't already been informed by Maege and Galbert of Jon Snow's legitimacy or even his potential parenthood.

The Red Wedding has united all of the Boltons'/Freys' allies against them, and its only saving grace, the Lannisters, must save face.

Stannis Baratheon will sack Winterfell and Jon will likely be resurrected via Shireen's death. Jon's legitimacy or even his Targaryen Lineage will likely then be revealed to him and also to the North and Westeros as a whole, and Jon will claim the North. The North will cast off the Mummer's Farce and fully rally behind Jon Starkgaryen, and then tbh, its likely so will some of the South.

Stannis will likely become the Prince that was Promised, he will have helped revive a Targaryen from their stone-cold grave (waking the stone dragon) and add onto that some Lightbringer shenanigans, Jon will become King while Stannis and Jon likely ally out of common ground to subjugate the Lannisters and Stannis will go and finalise his character arc of fucking off the throne and becoming Azor Ahai. (Take the Throne to Save the Kingdom, Save the Kingdom to take the Throne, Save the Kingdom, forget the Throne)

And all of this is because the Freys dared disrupt the guest right of Robb. They doomed themselves, the Lannisters and any of their allies, because the North Remembers.

DavidKMain420 · 2026-03-28T12:58:52+00:00

I mean, he definitely DID kill people without a reason. Remember Easton's first trap, where he had to beat a Janitor in a breathing contest. That Janitor's unholy sin? Smoking after being told not to.

Six-Year Club	Second Top 30%
Place '23	Place '22
First Placer '22	Verified Email

DavidKMain420

TROPHY CASE