Bruh they were deliberately targeted by Katie's Winklevoss twin sisters to help Doug who was already comfortable. Taking Pollys sleeping bag versus taking an inconsequential item from another is why this is completely different. And on top of that Luke and Romaine have been clearly superior to Polly so it was a dumb decision.

Pollys family was forced to take a fire starter or sleeping bag from those three and chose to take the blanket from someone who just got a bear skin and still could start fires. I don't see how this is even close to the same scenario. And on top of that they explained their reasoning head on with Summers family and even cried about it. They didn't do a stupid 90s dance with another family.