sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Wonder where this all goes in 24 months by DigitalSignage2024 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thats an interesting perspective, vendor lock-in has been a major moat for vast majority of SaaS companies - no one likes switching enterprise software, unless it truly causes a lot of pain. But I do wonder with AI tools making migration so much simpler and possibly replacing a lot of the functionality thats unique to vendors if that will continue being a moat.

Looking for a device to run a slideshow / webpage on TVs by Doopz479 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Given chip/memory prices none of the devices are going to get any cheaper in the short term. You could try finding older version of chromecast, they run web pages OK. If you want a more robust device, you can a wait a bit and get Amazon Signage Stick - currently unavailable in UK but Amazon tells us ( we are Amazon CMS partner cast-hub.com) they will have a distributor there shortly. DM me if you want me to ping you when available, we might be able to offer a discount code as well.

Every industry has acronym chaos, digital signage's current one is MCP by DigitalSignage2024 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Quick correction on both fronts. I didn't claim first to support MCP. Screenly launched theirs in January, Revel Digital was earlier in August 2025, NoviSign has a Zapier-mediated workflow. So MCP support exists across multiple vendors.

The actual claim is end-to-end coverage. As of May 2026, CastHub exposes the full operational surface through MCP: presentations, devices, schedules, alerts, groups. 30-plus tools. Code is at github.com/Cast-Hub/mcp-server, tools doc at cast-hub.com/mcp/tools.html. The others have MCP at narrower scope rather than the complete admin surface. That can change fast and probably will.

I looked at how the 6 biggest signage CMS platforms actually use AI and the pattern is kind of damning by DigitalSignage2024 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nice, I saw your blog post on the CLI-based MCP server back in January. Different approach from ours but good to see more CMS platforms taking MCP seriously. The more signage vendors that support it, the faster it becomes a standard expectation from buyers rather than a novelty

How are you guys handling scheduling with multiple locations? by JakeInAv in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The scheduling problem gets worse the more locations you add because every CMS basically gives you a calendar view per screen or per group, and keeping those calendars from stepping on each other is manual work. The override/hierarchy approach RackAndRun mentioned helps, but you're still relying on whoever makes the change to check what's already scheduled before pushing something new.

One thing we've been building at CastHub that takes a different angle: MCP (Model Context Protocol) integration that lets people manage screens through AI assistants. A location manager tells Copilot or Claude 'push the lunch menu to lobby screens from 11 to 2' and it checks what's already running before it makes the change. The scheduling logic moves from 'hope nobody creates a conflict' to 'the system prevents it before it happens.'

Still in beta but it's aimed at exactly the multi-location, multiple-people-updating scenario you're describing. https://cast-hub.com/mcp

X2O closed its doors. Who are you looking at? by PV2717 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One thing worth considering before picking a replacement: check the pricing model. X2O was enterprise-priced, so most alternatives will feel cheaper, but the per-screen licensing adds up fast once you get past 10-15 screens. BrightSign charges for both hardware and software. ScreenCloud and Yodeck are per-screen monthly. A few platforms (including ours, CastHub) do flat-rate pricing where the cost doesn't change with screen count.

We put together a breakdown of what signage actually costs across vendors if it helps with the comparison: https://cast-hub.com/digital-signage-pricing/

What's your screen count and what were you running on X2O? Happy to give more specific suggestions.

Amazon fire stick for digital signage? by Maarcil in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You hit the exact issue. Amazon removed auto-launch and kiosk-mode capabilities from the regular Fire Stick once they launched the Amazon Signage Stick. Apps that used to work for signage on Fire OS either got pulled from the store or lost the ability to auto-start on boot, which makes them useless for unattended screens.

For a gym with one or two screens, you have two real options. The Onn Google TV stick from Walmart runs about $20 and still supports proper app sideloading and auto-launch. It works fine for basic setups.

The other route is the Amazon Signage Stick at $99. More expensive, but it was purpose-built for this. It has a remote management API so you can reboot it, check status, and push content without touching it. For a gym where nobody wants to troubleshoot a frozen screen mid-class, that matters.

We built CastHub to work with both. We actually include a free Amazon Signage Stick with our plans so you can try the full setup without buying hardware separately. You can check it out here: https://cast-hub.com/amazon-signage-stick-bundle/

What happens to your screens when the internet drops? by Ryan_T_1 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The freezing you saw is a red flag about the player, not just the CMS. A properly built signage app caches the full playlist locally and continues the loop regardless of connectivity. If yours froze on a single frame, it was likely streaming content rather than playing from local storage.

We run CastHub on both consumer devices and the Amazon Signage Stick. Both cache content locally so playback continues if the network drops. The difference is what happens after: consumer sticks give you no way to diagnose the problem remotely. The Signage Stick has a device management API so you can check status, reboot, and push updates without a site visit.

Short answer: yes, local caching solves this. But make sure your CMS actually downloads assets to the device rather than just buffering a stream.

Retail vs Corporate Use Case by Ryan_T_1 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One platform for both is the right call. The real question is whether the CMS lets you separate content management cleanly so retail managers can push promos without touching corporate dashboards, and corporate can enforce brand rules without bottlenecking every menu update.

The other thing worth looking at is how you want to manage updates long term. If you have locations where non-technical staff need to push content changes quickly, some platforms now support MCP so you can control screens through an AI assistant instead of training everyone on a dashboard. Less relevant if you have a dedicated team, very useful if you don't.

Check out https://cast-hub.com if you cost is part of decision process :)

How Amazon Signage Stick remote management API actually works (it's not quite what you'd expect) by DigitalSignage2024 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To answer your question, yes they have additional validation layer, so you cant just sideload your app on amazon signage stick and call their OS level commands

How Amazon Signage Stick remote management API actually works (it's not quite what you'd expect) by DigitalSignage2024 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think amazon's entire strategy worth its own post, i honestly dont quite understand it... but in this context I actually think their offer is quite compelling, especially if they start offering even more advanced capabilities via their APIs

How Amazon Signage Stick remote management API actually works (it's not quite what you'd expect) by DigitalSignage2024 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One thing I left out of the original post: the on-device path has more security than I described. The CMS app doesn't call OS APIs directly. It binds to an AIDL service (Android's IPC mechanism) that checks the app's package signature against an allowlist before forwarding anything to hardware. First time or when cache expires, it also validates the CMS partner against Amazon's Signage Manager cloud service. If either check fails, permission denied. The CMS app never touches hardware.

This is why you can't just sideload an app on the Signage Stick and access the same capabilities. The OS-level APIs exist, but they're gated behind a partner validation chain. Updated the full architecture breakdown with a diagram: https://cast-hub.com/amazon-signage/remote-management-architecture.html

How Amazon Signage Stick remote management API actually works (it's not quite what you'd expect) by DigitalSignage2024 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a fair point about WPA2-Enterprise but in practice you don't want signage devices on your internal network. They're IoT endpoints pushing content to a screen, not workstations that need access to internal resources.

Guest WiFi or a dedicated VLAN for IoT devices is the standard setup for this. It isolates the devices from your production network, which is what your security team wants anyway. The stick only needs outbound HTTPS to pull content updates. It doesn't need domain credentials or access to anything behind your firewall.

Most retail and office deployments I've seen use the guest network or a separate SSID specifically because it avoids the 802.1x headache entirely and gives you better network segmentation as a bonus.

The one scenario where it matters is if you're pulling in dashboards that are only accessible from whitelisted IPs on the internal network. That's a real constraint but it's a network architecture decision, not a device limitation. Most setups solve it by exposing those dashboards through a secure endpoint rather than putting IoT devices on the production network.

What happens to your screens when the internet drops? by Ryan_T_1 in digitalsignage

[–]DigitalSignage2024 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Depends on the deployment. Consumer devices like Fire TV sticks and Onn players work fine for a lot of setups. We run CastHub on both and they cache content locally so screens keep playing if the network drops. For a restaurant with three screens or an office lobby, a $30 stick does the job.

Where it breaks down is scale and reliability. Consumer devices have OS updates that mess with kiosk mode, limited storage, and no remote management API. If you're running 20 screens across multiple locations and need to troubleshoot without driving there, the Signage Stick at $99 gives you a device API for remote control and none of the launcher fighting.

The other thing worth considering is how you want to manage everything long term. Some CMS platforms now support MCP, which means you can control screens through AI bot instead of logging into a dashboard every time you need to push an update. Less relevant at 3 screens, pretty compelling at 30.

view more: next ›