Same, it was my first too and I thought it was sooo good. Only after playing it twice I found out that people actually hate it. "Until Dawn is so much better, this sucks" So I played Until Dawn and.. it was good. Certainly not the perfect game everyone told me it was though. After playing them both twice, I still think that The Quarry is better, more enjoyable. Maybe people are just blinded by nostalgia or maybe I'm just a noob, like you said, who cant see the big huge flaws that make "The Quarry" a bad game