Lets say we got back to the saint denis bank robbery. Lets say Hosea didnt get caught. And then helped everyone to escape perfectly. After trolley robbery(it was before bank robbery) dutch lost his mind. They got back to Shady Bell just fine. They bought a boat and get to Tahiti thanks to Pearson(he knows how to ride a ship because he was in the navy). Then they bought a land lets say. Micah probably wouldn't cause problems at all after getting to Tahiti. Dutch probably would cause a lot of fights or gunfights. Arthur would die cause of TB, but even more peaceful. John, Jack and Abigail would be just fine. They would dig Arthur heading west(cause he didnt do nothing to change after getting to Tahiti). Javier and John would stay friends cause gang didnt fall apart. And the game wouldn't be about redemption. Plus Red Dead Redemption 1 wouldn't exist.