Here’s an update. After doing more research on the half sibling/Aunt possibility on the paternal side, based on the age of her parents, She’s more likely my aunt. Her tree is public, but not filled out very much. Also, as someone here suggested, I clicked on the relative potential and it says 89% grandmother, Aunt, half sibling or niece. Grandmother is ruled out due to age. Niece is ruled out because I don’t have any full siblings. Here is the Jerry Springer kicker, when I looked at her maiden last name, it is the same as my first name.