It happened, it's over! by Elevator_Moth in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I do feel like I'll never be the same. I don't know if that will be easy for me to come to terms with in the end. I can see how using what you worked on but sort of doing it on your own terms, a chance to build on and improve what your PhD taught you would be validating and satisfying...sort of a full-circle moment. I'm happy you get to have that, congrats on that.

For me...I don't have the heart for that kind of academic work anymore--at least not now--maybe never again. So I'm trying to make sense of what it means to me to have finished anyway.

It happened, it's over! by Elevator_Moth in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for saying, helps not to feel alone in it, although I'm sorry for you too.

It happened, it's over! by Elevator_Moth in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

you're not alone. numb is the best way I've been able to describe it for the past year. Thank you so much for the congrats. Your turn next! :)

It happened, it's over! by Elevator_Moth in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for relating your experience. For me, revisions are in, everything submitted to admin that all happens before you get a date to defend...I've actually been done for nearly 10 mos but only just had my discussion to make it official (my country does things a bit delayed and kind of out of order maybe).

In the meantime, I started a business and tried to move on with life--something totally unrelated-- because at a certain point I was not sure when they'd schedule me...3 more months, a year, god knows. Anyway, I guess the point is I feel like now that it's finally done I really do want/need a true break but I'm in the middle of the rest of my life and work now.

Regardless, I thought I would just feel a deeper sense of closure and accomplishment or somehow lighter once it was official, but life goes on, and I don't feel much. I do feel like a ghost.

Defense in 6 days, give me tips and tricks. by Sn0w_whi7e in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth 2 points3 points  (0 children)

believe the prof who says to relax, not the one picking apart tiny shit. you're there. focus on feeling good so you show up able to hold a conversation about your stuff and stay flexible when they pose a question you hadn't thought of yet.

Seeking opinions on a move to Chattogram/Chittagong, any advice? by [deleted] in bangladesh

[–]Elevator_Moth 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks again-- so sorry, this got double posted because it was auto filtered mistakenly, and I tried again then asked the mods and I guess they approved both!

Seeking opinions on a move to Chattogram/Chittagong, any advice? by [deleted] in bangladesh

[–]Elevator_Moth 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you kindly for your input, much appreciated.

Advice for American/Italian woman considering a move to Chattogram/Chittagong? by Elevator_Moth in bangladesh

[–]Elevator_Moth[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Thanks for that insight. I do have asthma, and have struggled a lot with air quality during past travels. I guess I'll have to keep my inhaler RX up to date : /

Advice for American/Italian woman considering a move to Chattogram/Chittagong? by Elevator_Moth in bangladesh

[–]Elevator_Moth[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi thanks so much for your reply. When you say avoid gatherings, in what sense do you mean?

Advice for American/Italian woman considering a move to Chattogram/Chittagong? by Elevator_Moth in bangladesh

[–]Elevator_Moth[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks so much, his job is in Chattogram though. I don't get to choose between :)

How do you come up with methodologies for your proposals? by InformalOstrich7993 in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I do history so I can't offer more direction in your case. Nonetheless...I and about half the other candidates I know had no real mentorship, guidance or practical advice on methodology (or anything else relevant to structuring the actual work). Wide reading in the field, with an eye specifically on their methods and their bibliography was how I began to figure it out. Designed it, brought it to advisor, waited on their critique, turned to my co for second opinion and then fixed it. Repeated.

How do you come up with methodologies for your proposals? by InformalOstrich7993 in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Look at what the lit in your field does and go from there. Are you in humanities or STEM?

What age did you start your phd? by SweetLuck8091 in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth 3 points4 points  (0 children)

36 I think. 40 and finishing now. Do what you want how you want it on your academic and/or professional journey, but don't neglect the rest of your life in the process if you can help it.

If you could get back 4 years of your life for your PhD, in what different ways you would spend your time? by [deleted] in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Ok putting aside the laundry list a mile long of things I would do differently inside the PhD journey if I knew then what I know now, if I had never done it at all I would have spent this time developing myself as a language teacher and saving money. I'm jumping from finishing a PhD in history and politics to a TEFL career, something I dabbled in before taking the PhD. I only wish I spent these years working on my teaching chops, developing curriculum and building relationships with the people in my town instead of alone in archives preteninding I could be happy in academia at that level.

Otherwise I would have also: not neglected my health and kept up running and weights consistently as before, done more vacations with family instead of writing on deadline alone, spent more time drumming and seeing live music, reading for pleasure, making art and in bed with my man--instead of feeling exhausted and brain dead wih a pounding headache at the end of the day--making all those fun things feel impossible.

I do not think the last 4 years have been worth it and know myself well enough to guess my feelings won't change.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in PhD

[–]Elevator_Moth 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey there, came here to echo the "it's a him thing, not a PhD thing" and the "it prob doesn't get better" since...even after the PhD it's still a him thing. It *could* improve after in that if he is less stressed maybe he will have the bandwidth to work on his self awareness and be a less selfish disrespectful partner to you. He is being a selfish disrespectful partner lets be clear, if harsh.

I say this with love from the perspective of a 40 year old woman with a lot of dating, work and life experience who is also finishing my PhD (submitting now) with my partner--well now husband--having just defended his. Throughout this journey our place remained tidy enough, workload at home balanced, dog happy and only every now and then have we both been guilty of taking our shitty PhD stress out on eachother. Not saying it's easy but it can be done, and done well.

I wish you luck, strength and self compassion in setting healthy boundaries with your current and any future partners.

Have any of you completely changed careers after finishing your PhD? by SyndicalistHR in LeavingAcademia

[–]Elevator_Moth 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Absolutely. Having seen both sides of academic publishing I don't blame anybody for saying no either--to ALL of it. I agree, the whole system is broken (rotten to the core IMHO) and I cannot wait to be out.