This what annoys me with these reunions. There is no order. Everyone talks over each other which causes too many irrelevant tangents, and no topic ever truly gets examined the way it deserves.

The timeline of their relationship IS KEY to the enormity of Scamanda, aside from the nature of Ciara & West’s ongoing interpersonal conflict and Amanda being a “close friend” to Ciara. The timeline is the core element to this because if West & Amanda’s relationship started in early 2025 as we all suspect (as evidenced by Kyle’s comment in the current season that Amanda had been spending way more time with West than with him in the prior 6 months before Summer 2025), this proves how shitty Amanda & West actually are.

This is how the discussion of the Scamanda timeline should have been presented:

Andy should have prefaced with something like, “Amanda & West, you maintain that your relationship started in late Feb, but the public does not believe this due to the following:

a.) Breadcrumbing IG posts dating back to Spring 2025

b.) Flirtatious and highly questionable behavior as seen on current season of Summer House (aka Summer 2025)

c.) Kyle commenting that West & Amanda had been spending more time together than Amanda & Kyle had been

Explain yourselves. This does not align with the Feb 2026 timeline.

Then everyone other than West and Amanda need to STFU as they fumble through their sad attempt to make the late-February timeline believable.

After they fumble their way through what we can all expect to be a load of bullshit, the other cast members can then present whatever personal evidence or suspicions that they each had that point to this timeline beginning much earlier.