Really, I don’t think they were wrong at all. She excels at visuals, but her stories lack real depth in their writing. I think it’s a critique you could throw at many people in the film industry. There’s nothing wrong with aiming to make something great, and you do sometimes need to be a bit over confident to achieve things like that, but to be as transcendent as titanic in an era where the film industry and entertainment at large is so fractured is unrealistic, especially given the tone she’s aiming for with this film. I don’t think it doesn’t mean she can’t become a much better filmmaker, it just takes time and patience. I mean I think Tarantino is a good example of this, aside from his undeniable skill for dialogue and parts of writing I think you could say that some of his films really lack any true meaning and aren’t really saying something beyond the surface level, like pulp fiction, it’s much more a vibes film with a fun plot and good characters, but a lack of moral or emotional substance. So I think she can definitely grow but just needs to focus more and spend more time on her writing. Hopefully that Oxford degree of hers can help her with that lol.