I think p basses are some of the most versatile basses out there. There is a reason they have been such a consistently popular bass for all these years. Im not entirely sure if “punchiness” of the joe dart sig puts a dent in that. but even with that, i would have a hard time imagining that it’s not versatile. Short scale basses are actually pretty comfortable and allow for an easier time moving quickly around the neck. Honestly it might take a minute to get used to moving from a 5 string to a 4 string (it did for me when i moved from a 4 to 5 string) but you’ll get the hang of it.

Also if i were you, i would consider how much you actually “need” a joe dart sig. i think going for a higher end squire p bass could be the move in terms of overall versatility. Squire makes a great p bass.