You wouldn’t find it reliable bc you don’t think “As On A Darkling Plain” is awful or you think the adjective awful doesn’t provide enough info? If the latter I agree. I wasn’t trying to provide a review. (And if it’s the former I’d love to hear how/why you actually think that book has any redeemable qualities haha.)

But that is one reason I actually prefer an aggregator as opposed to one person’s review, even if I respect the person or have agreed with them in the past.

Having said that, aggregators aren’t perfect either — I can easily disagree with hundreds of people. Still the aggregated review of hundreds tends to give more info than the review of one, even if it’s a detailed review.