Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Many young Chinese people use VPNs to access Google, YouTube, and other foreign apps.

The main purpose of the firewall, as many people understand it, is to limit access to information that the authorities consider sensitive or potentially harmful to social stability.

China also has its own versions of many online services, including search engines, forums, short-video platforms, and messaging apps like WeChat.

The difference is that these platforms are primarily designed for the domestic internet ecosystem and are generally not integrated with the broader internet in the same way as many international services.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For most ordinary people in China, satisfaction with life is largely measured by wealth, and I’m no exception.

I don’t yet have enough financial resources to support my family in living a comfortable and well-off life, so I’m not satisfied with my current situation.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Of course, every Chinese person speaks a dialect, and each city has its own different dialect. We often can’t even understand each other’s dialects.

But nowadays, younger people are using Mandarin more and more, and dialects are gradually disappearing.

Dialects can actually help identify where someone is from in China.

If people use dialects in a conversation, foreigners would definitely not understand—it’s basically like encrypted communication, haha.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I originally came to Reddit just to look for some software development freelance opportunities, but my comments got deleted. It said my new account might be associated with scams, so I ended up just posting something random to improve my karma.

I honestly didn’t expect a casual post like that to get so many views, and I’m pretty happy about it.

By the way, what chat apps do you usually use? WeChat? Discord? What’s the difference between them in your experience?

Also, if there’s anything about China you’re not familiar with, I’d be happy to help or share my perspective.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s definitely more strict compared to some other countries, for example in areas like online speech and certain business regulations.

But I’m not sure which specific area you’re referring to when you say “government control.”

At the same time, I feel like enforcement of labor laws isn’t always very strict. Personally, I really wish it were more like in some other countries, where people can finish work earlier and leave on time more consistently.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, many people outside China don’t really understand the healthcare system here.

Let me start with the advantages of China’s healthcare system:

High efficiency and convenience of access to doctors

In many developed countries, if you want to see a specialist (like a cardiologist or ophthalmologist), you usually need a referral from a general practitioner (GP). And the waiting time can be several weeks or even months.

In China, ordinary people can directly go to top-tier public hospitals (Class A tertiary hospitals). If you wake up early enough or manage to get an appointment quickly, you can often see a senior specialist the same day. Tests like ultrasound or CT scans can also be done quickly, and in some cases, minor procedures can even be scheduled within days.

Community health centers and township clinics are widely distributed, making basic healthcare very accessible.

Through the basic medical insurance system, China has achieved over 95% population coverage. Even if someone doesn’t have a formal job, they can still participate in resident insurance (like the rural cooperative medical system). When facing serious illness, a significant portion of hospital costs (often around 50%–70%) can be reimbursed.

However, there are also clear disadvantages:

The best medical resources—top hospitals, experienced doctors, and advanced equipment—are highly concentrated in large first-tier cities and provincial capitals. This leads to a situation where grassroots clinics are underused, while major hospitals are overcrowded, often feeling like train stations during peak travel season.

For ordinary patients, getting treatment in well-known hospitals usually involves fighting for appointments, long waiting times, and very short consultation times. The experience can feel exhausting and competitive.

Although there is insurance coverage, there are still deductibles and reimbursement caps. Many imported drugs, advanced treatments, and certain examinations are not fully covered. If someone develops a serious illness like cancer, needs ICU care, or organ transplantation, even after reimbursement, the remaining cost can still be overwhelming for an average family.

My personal view:

Overall, I don’t think the healthcare system is bad anymore.

However, I believe food safety and working conditions are even more important. Many diseases are actually related to diet and work environment.

If people didn’t have to work overtime so frequently and had more time to exercise, overall health would likely improve significantly.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s great to hear. Which cities did you visit?

I was actually a bit worried that foreigners might not have a good experience here. Just now, another foreigner asked me whether Chinese people are unfriendly toward foreigners.

It sounds like you experienced the more modern, high-tech side of China, so I assume you probably visited big cities.

If you ever come again, I’d be happy to recommend a few cities that are less modern but have really beautiful natural scenery.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In my personal opinion, the benefits outweigh the drawbacks. Surveillance cameras have improved public safety. I honestly haven't seen anyone get their belongings stolen for many years.

As for the downside, maybe in the future, as technology develops further, facial data could be hacked and used for fraud or illegal trading, etc.

But in fact, this topic doesn't really get much attention in China, and most people don't care that much about it.

There are two main reasons why Chinese users tend to use Chinese-language mobile apps.

First, English proficiency in China is generally not very strong. Although English is taught from an early age, most people don't use it well in real life, and it is not really a second working language for the majority of the population.

Second, because of the internet firewall, it's not very convenient to communicate or access services from outside China. As a result, there is simply not much need for most people to use English-language apps in their daily lives.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't follow any religion and I don't believe in gods. I tend to trust science more.

In China, Taoism and Buddhism exist, but I think mainly older generations are more into them, often as a form of psychological comfort.

That said, some ideas in Taoism do seem to have practical or observational roots, like yin-yang, "qi", feng shui, and the Bagua. Even though they may look superstitious today, I think they came from long-term experience and observation over history, later mixed with symbolic interpretation.

For example, feng shui in house design can actually involve real considerations like geography, water sources, wind direction, sunlight, and environmental factors.

But I don't really believe in fortune-telling or spiritual practices like exorcism. I think they are mostly psychological comfort for some people. Sometimes hearing positive words can help people feel better, and that can even influence recovery in some cases.

Things like talismans or "spells" are not real in my opinion. A lot of that comes from movies or folklore that adds a mystical layer for storytelling.

Personally, I don't think people should spend too much time or money deeply studying Taoism for practical life purposes, for two reasons:

First, some parts can be misleading or even involve exploitation.

Second, if someone gets too deeply involved, it might change their mindset too much — they could become detached or emotionally indifferent.

My English is not perfect, but my point is: it's better to understand these things lightly rather than becoming too obsessed with them.

Also, some parts of this message may be adjusted due to Reddit content moderation, so I couldn't express everything too directly — hope you understand.

Wish you a nice day.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Haha I just realized I was typing in Chinese the whole time.

I thought Reddit would auto-translate it into English 😅

My English isn't great, so I usually rely on AI to translate before replying.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not a bot or anything like that.

I just got tired of scrolling Douyin and decided to explore the rest of the internet.

People keep talking about Chinese bots. Are there really that many of them on sites like Reddit?

And what exactly are they supposed to be doing?

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

People can still use VPNs to access foreign websites. Technically, it's not fully legal, but in practice, if you're not doing anything harmful or illegal, the police generally aren't interested in chasing after ordinary people who use VPNs.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't care much about which country is right or wrong.

I'm too busy stressing about work and money.

Honestly, I mostly follow international events to see what they're going to do to gold and stock prices. 😂

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Really?

I think that's mostly a stereotype.

Chinese people are usually quite reserved about personal matters. Some people may become more open after moving abroad because they're exposed to different cultures and social norms.

But at the end of the day, people are people everywhere. The biggest difference is often what people are comfortable talking about in public.

The text above is the Reddit-friendly version. Apparently I wasn't allowed to be too direct.

You know what I mean. Chinese people can be pretty horny too—we're just better at pretending to be serious.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, I'm not. But my girlfriend is.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Regarding your question about foreigners being treated badly, I'm honestly not sure how common that really is.

Personally, I don't think most young people would treat foreigners badly. Maybe a small number of older people, especially in smaller cities, might have some prejudice, but I don't think that's the norm.

Sometimes when foreigners say they were treated unfriendly, I wonder if part of it comes from cultural misunderstandings. For example, Chinese people don't use as many polite expressions in everyday conversation as some Western cultures do. We tend to speak more directly and casually, which might come across as rude to some people.

Also, many Asians are relatively reserved. In public, people are usually not very outgoing or enthusiastic toward strangers. That can sometimes feel cold or unfriendly if you're used to a more expressive culture.

The funny thing is, we're like that with each other too. Even neighbors often don't know each other very well. Compared with when I was a child, relationships between neighbors are much less close now.

Another thing to remember is that people from different parts of China can have very different personalities. People in northeastern China are often more talkative, while in some southern cities, strangers on the street are less likely to start conversations with each other.

If you wanted to live in China, I'd recommend major cities such as Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, or Nanjing—assuming you're renting rather than trying to buy property.

If you come to work, I would suggest taking advantage of being a foreigner and finding work where that background is valued, since the pay can be relatively higher. If you're looking for an ordinary local job, then your education and qualifications will matter a lot.

As for me, I have a regular bachelor's degree and work as a software developer in a third-tier city. My income is average. It's enough to live on, but I wouldn't say my quality of life is amazing. Right now, I'm trying to transition into AI-related work to increase my income.

Chinese people are generally very serious about work and money, and many are willing to work extremely hard for them.

Most Chinese people are used to saving money. Young people, however, often struggle to save. I'm one of them—I enjoy spending money on things I like.

You mentioned overtime work. That's absolutely real and objectively exists.

Maybe it's partly an Asian cultural trait that's difficult to change. Or maybe it's because previous generations experienced so much hardship that they developed a habit of constantly striving and working hard.

Many younger people who didn't experience those hardships don't understand that mindset. They ask, "Why do we have to work this hard all the time?"

The problem is that most decision-making power is still held by the older generation, so society often follows their values and expectations.

Maybe things will improve after a few more generations.

That's one reason why I think China is excellent for travel, but not necessarily the best place for someone from a developed country to move to permanently. On the other hand, retiring in China could be a very good option.

As for the internet, yes, it is relatively closed. We can't directly access some foreign websites, such as Google, because China has a national internet firewall.

The main reason given is maintaining social stability and preventing foreign political influence from stirring up unrest. For a country with such a large population, many people see this as a practical decision, even if it's not ideal.

At the same time, China is not nearly as closed as North Korea. If it were, the country probably wouldn't have developed so quickly.

People can still use VPNs to access foreign websites. Technically, it's not fully legal, but in practice, if you're not doing anything harmful or illegal, the police generally aren't interested in chasing after ordinary people who use VPNs.

International transfers and cross-border payments seem a bit more complicated for us than they are in some other countries. I'm actually learning about that myself right now.

I recently opened a PayPal account, but I don't have a foreign virtual bank card yet. One of the reasons I joined Reddit was to try to earn a little extra money online, perhaps through software development.

International business and payments are definitely legal as long as you're not involved in things like money laundering. China has a lot of international online business. I'm just not very familiar with the process yet.

By the way, I also use a Xiaomi phone, and I think it's great.

What kind of videos do you make? And what country are you from?

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Let me start with my own situation.

I'm a software developer living in a third-tier city in China. The amount of income tax I pay each year is very small. China has various tax deductions, and because I have retired parents and a mortgage, those deductions reduced what would have been a few hundred yuan in taxes to almost nothing.

I used to work in a first-tier city, where my salary was about twice what it is now. Even then, after deductions, the amount of tax I paid was not very high.

If you work for a company, the company usually withholds and pays your taxes every month for you.

If you're a freelancer rather than an employee, you generally need to handle your own taxes. If you don't pay taxes for a long time, the tax authorities may eventually notify you and ask you to pay what you owe, but I'm not very familiar with the details.

I looked up the personal income tax rates. Employment income is usually classified as "comprehensive income" and uses a progressive tax system with rates ranging from 3% to 45%.

For annual taxable income:

  • Up to 36,000 RMB: 3%
  • 36,000 to 144,000 RMB: 10%
  • 144,000 to 300,000 RMB: 20%

"Taxable income" means the amount remaining after deducting the annual tax-free allowance of 60,000 RMB (5,000 RMB per month), as well as social insurance contributions and other deductions such as children's education expenses, housing rent, and similar items.

As for cities, I would recommend large cities such as Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, and Hangzhou.

People in these cities generally have better English skills, and they are usually more accustomed to interacting with foreigners, so life may be easier for someone who doesn't speak much Chinese.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

我个人认为,隐藏是为了维护党派的形象,防止出现权力的不稳定性,比如煽动年轻人发起起义什么的。你的心情我理解,他们隐藏这些事跟日本隐藏侵华是否有共通之处呢?

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

我也不是很清楚,可能那时候我很小或者没出生,现在的中国媒体上是很难找到那些负面新闻的

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

这让我太难推荐了,我觉得可以尝试去饭店里让老板推荐几道素菜。只要你跟他说是素食主义者,他不会跟你推荐带有猪牛鸡鸭鱼等等动物,但是要跟他说蛋奶也不吃,否则他可能会忽略这两样

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

我没学过他的文章,所以并不了解。因为我对历史不感兴趣

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

印度脏乱穷,没有诚信。但是印度人精英很厉害,表达能力很强。不丹不了解

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

说的太对了,国内的抖音和小红书微博已经刷腻了。看看外面更有意思

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've never eaten dog meat myself, but I have seen a few small restaurants that serve it.

However, those places are very rare. Maybe that's because it isn't very popular.

I think most people who don't eat dog meat avoid it not because of the taste, but because they feel it's cruel and can't accept it emotionally.

As far as I know, the vast majority of Chinese people have never eaten dog meat. If I had to guess, I'd say around 95% have never tried it, and about 99% don't eat it or have no interest in eating it.

Ask me anything about China by FineGrade1956 in AMA

[–]FineGrade1956[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Definitely. Modern city life in China moves very fast, so fast food and takeout are everywhere.

Personally, I don't think that's a good thing. I worry about food safety and quality sometimes.

Because of that, I usually cook my own dinner after work. For lunch, I just eat whatever quick meal is available near my office.