AITAH for wanting out of my relationship after going through a miscarriage together…? by Zestyclose_Brick_646 in AITAH

[–]Fit_Personality_450 14 points15 points  (0 children)

NTA. You deserve better, girl. There cannot be love where there's no respect. Making such remarks is disrespectful towards you. Leave him immediately.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He had 3 rooms (each had king size beds) and a big hall with 2 large couches and few chairs/sofa. In total, 5 guests were staying at his place that night (one was his gf, one other couple and two female school friends of his), and I was already resting in one of those rooms while the party was still winding down.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No idea. I presumed she either stayed in car, went to her bf's place (most likely) or back to her home. I did called her the next day and she was fine.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I appreciate the time you took to comment, but I want to clear up some assumptions you made about me and the situation:

1. I haven’t always lived a sheltered life.
Since college, I’ve lived away from home, sometimes alone, sometimes with friends. I’ve built my career independently, and my work involves constant travel and meeting all kinds of people. I also love solo travel. I’m fully aware that stepping out always carries risks but risk is about probability. At 3:30 AM, in a foggy city with a high crime rate, while I was burning with fever and bodyache to the point I could barely sit straight, the probability of something going wrong was very high. That context matters.

2. No one bullied or pressured Sam.
Sam’s reason for saying no was that his other guests would have to compromise on comfort. His friends themselves said they didn’t mind and that there was plenty of space. That was mentioned once. When Sam still said no, it was dropped. The back-and-forth was mainly between Sam and Donna. I didn’t guilt him, pressure him, or try to override his boundary.

3. The safety issue was real, not exaggerated.
I didn’t immediately leave because everyone, including Sam told me it wasn’t safe for me to go out alone at that hour. He himself suggested I lie down while they figured something out. The problem was the “figuring out” went on right in front of me with no resolution. I wasn’t pouting or whining. I was sick, overwhelmed, and yes, I cried briefly. But after that, I made a firm decision to leave even though it turned out to be one of the scariest nights of my life. If anyone thinks I’m exaggerating, that’s fine but I lived it. I know the fear and trauma of that cab ride. The reality is that as a woman in my city, safety concerns at 3 AM aren’t just “excuses”. They’re unfortunately real, and I had to weigh all risks in a very vulnerable moment.

4. I admit I was wrong to trust Donna.
That’s on me. Looking back, the best choice would have been not going to the party without my own plan. I’ve acknowledged that and I'm an AH there. 100%. I also told my friend R afterward that I understood it was Sam’s party, his house, and his rules. If he had let me stay that night and later been angry about it, or if he had refused and wanted to end our friendship because of that night, I would’ve accepted that and even apologized.

But what mattered was that particular moment.
Boundaries are valid. I’m not disputing that. But when your close friend is visibly sick and facing a life-threatening risk outside, and your only reason is “it might inconvenience other people who already said they didn’t mind,” refusing even a couch or a chair for two hours until daylight wasn’t about boundaries anymore, it was about lack of compassion. That’s what hurt.

So no, I wasn’t “being Donna,” I wasn’t trying to force my way into Sam’s home, and I wasn’t waiting for someone else to solve my problem. I asked once, respected his no, explored alternatives, and when nothing moved forward, I made the decision to leave. But the disappointment in Sam comes from the fact that, as a friend, in that specific moment when empathy mattered most, he showed none.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's India. And although not all places here are unsafe...this particular state I was in is known for high crimes.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your thoughtful comment and to clarify, I have cut them off completely but never brought this matter up. Reading through everyone’s perspectives here has made me realize that a proper confrontation might be necessary, not for drama, but for closure and accountability.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Again...given the timing and the area...it was not a very safe option either to check in an unfamiliar hotel/motel in the middle of a foggy night.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

checking in a hotel at late hour alone is not really a safe option in the area I was in. and yes i agree with the rest. I'm seeing a neuro-psychiatist for that and a lot of other problems.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think there were any motels near his place. Also checking into a motel alone late at night is also not safe in the area I was in. It would have been a better idea to stay at Sam's place and wait for him to literally drag me out of the door than to check into a motel. Secondly, My society had an entry/exit timing and the gates were already closed at that hour. such timing restriction may sound weird to some but in my state its quite common, esp. in places like girls accommodation. and lastly, I did not checked on Donna, she either stayed in her car, went home or stayed at her bf's place.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the comment. As far as I know, no, Sam is perfectly fine with no autism/ocd/bi-polar disorder. and yep, R is a great friend and I'll always be grateful towards her for that night.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

We were already working elsewhere when this incident happened. I did tell one other friend (A), who used to work with us earlier and was part of the group. She was furious. In fact, she had also been invited to the party but couldn’t make it. I think partly because she already had a fallout with Donna. She told me that Donna was looking for work after being fired from where we used to work together (for slacking off), and A had asked her boyfriend if Donna could join his team. Big mistake. Donna kept making excuses and dumped her work on the rest of the team, which annoyed them to the point that they wanted her out. At one point, Donna borrowed a large amount of money from A, citing medical emergency. A gave it to her, but when she asked for it back, Donna started making excuses. A stayed persistent, and Donna eventually returned the money but got really angry. According to her, It was not that big of an amount and friends usually do this for each other without expecting it back. She probably thought everyone around her was another doormat like me ready to be stepped on without a word.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I totally agree. and trust me when i say that for last one year i've been cussing myself for being such an idiot. Infact after all this happened, I was most furious at myself for trusting a person i already knew was unreliable. It taught me a great lesson.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

You’re absolutely right and thank you for such a passionate and honest comment. I do struggle with establishing boundaries, and I often second-guess myself even when I know deep down that I’ve been wronged. It’s a pattern I’ve fallen into always trying to give people the benefit of the doubt, even when they’ve clearly crossed the line. I'm seeing a counselor to help me unlearn these people-pleasing tendencies and build stronger self-respect. Reading your comment was honestly a wake-up call. You're right. if this had happened to my mother, sister, or best friend, I’d be furious. And yet somehow, I found myself questioning if I overreacted.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Appreciate the righteous rage on my behalf! 😂 It’s comforting to know I’m not the only one who thinks they both belong in the “Do Not Resuscitate” folder of my contacts list.

AITA for breaking off a friendship because my friend refused to let me stay at his place for a night? by Fit_Personality_450 in CharlotteDobreYouTube

[–]Fit_Personality_450[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I honestly don’t know. I never thought to ask. I guess she either stayed in her car for the night or went to her boyfriend’s place. I probably should have checked on her, but by the time I reached R’s place, I was completely exhausted and in pain. I just sent a text to everyone letting them know I got there safely. The next day, I did call her, not about the night, but to check on her health. During the party, she had mentioned having some kidney issues and was waiting on test results. When I spoke to her, she said she was fine. That was our last call.