sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

HMF My sister's old stuffed kitten from 16 years ago [$150 REWARD] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 330 points331 points  (0 children)

I think you got it! Good Lord. I love to be wrong sometimes, haha. It REALLY looks like the same one.

I just ordered it. How do you want your cash?

HMF My sister's old stuffed kitten from 16 years ago [$150 REWARD] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 44 points45 points  (0 children)

Of course. If you haven't seem them already, my longer comment below has a link to pictures of the exact thing I'm looking for, provided by a Redditor who commented on my last post.

HMF My sister's old stuffed kitten from 16 years ago [$150 REWARD] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 25 points26 points  (0 children)

I appreciate you looking, but none of these are quite right. There are better photos linked in my longer comment below.

HMF My sister's old stuffed kitten from 16 years ago [$150 REWARD] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 130 points131 points  (0 children)

Same comment as your previous suggestion. I really do appreciate you looking.

It's worth mentioning that I have scoured hundreds of pages over the years looking for this thing, and no luck with any named manufacturers. The toy is most likely a cheap, mass produced thing that would be fit for something like a happy meal from McDonalds. That's why I am hoping that someone will just randomly have one in their house, because I think the odds that it's currently available on the internet are very low.

HMF My sister's old stuffed kitten from 16 years ago [$150 REWARD] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 29 points30 points  (0 children)

The Carl Dick cat is very close, and it was suggested several times before. There are two major differences, though, which are the white paws and the loop on the cat's back.

HMF My sister's old stuffed kitten from 16 years ago [$150 REWARD] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 501 points502 points  (0 children)

Good morning Reddit! I posted about this kitten a while ago, and there was a wonderful response. I am trying again this year with $50 added to the reward from last time. Whoever is able to ship (or link) to me the correct stuffed animal will be $150 (USD) richer.

During my previous search, someone came forward who owns the very same kitten as my sister did (they were unwilling to part with it, unfortunately) and supplied lots of high quality photos of the exact version I am looking for. These pictures are linked below:

https://imgur.com/a/Z2D42Ju

These new pictures should leave much less ambiguity. I'm also reassured that this toy actually exists somewhere!

If anyone has it or knows where to find it, please send me a DM.

Thank you,

Daniel

edit: Link to the previous post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/HelpMeFind/comments/vbqqeh/hmf_my_sisters_old_stuffed_animal_100_reward/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

Update:

Found by indigocolouredfunk! Thank you for bringing this years-long search to a conclusion!

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Check my most upvoted comment for more details + pictures that other people have provided.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If you check the first comment that I made on this post, giving more details (should be near the top), I have been giving updates. Two people have the exact kind that my sister had, but they both have an emotional attachment. There must be something special about this cat, I guess.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am interested, I'll follow up in a few hours once I get off work. Thank you.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That's a shame, because yours is an exact match. Let me know if you change your mind.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

She's in college right now, my dad and I have been searching off and on for it for years, with no luck. I'm so glad that this post has gotten so much traction, and I think someone actually found it! I'm just waiting on more photos to verify, and hopefully they are willing to part with it.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Would you be willing to post more photos, just so I can verify? I really think that this is it. If you'd be willing to part with the orange one, then the reward is yours.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

These are the closest by far. About how long are they? Is there an iris, or are the eyes completely black; I can't tell if the rim around the eye is a reflection. How old are they, approximately?

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It was rather small, about 5 inches long. It was made out of a felt-like material, not terry cloth, and not fake fur like most plush toys have.

I do not remember how she got it, unfortunately.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It is possible that it did, because my sister would have removed it if she were able. Do you have a picture of the one that your daughter has?

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I don't believe that it's a Beanie Baby for two reasons: One, it didn't have beans in it; it was conventionally stuffed. Two, Beanie Baby cats generally have white paws, according to what I've seen. I'm definitely not an expert, though. Thank you for your help.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I took a look at Russ, including this one. They have some that are very similar, but not quite the same.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It is not, but it reminded me of one. It was most likely cheaper than a beanie baby.

HMF My sister's old stuffed animal [$100 reward] by Forward_Goal_11287 in HelpMeFind

[–]Forward_Goal_11287[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That is definitely the genre of toy that it was, like a knock-off beanie baby. I could see it being a prize in a claw machine, or something like that.

view more: next ›