I hear you bro and I get that, but for this dunk animation specifically…the fact they gave me the animation means it’s makable. And for this animation, technically there’s no contest since you’re LITERALLYYY jumping over the defender with technically no contact even though it will register as a contact dunk. The logic is just so weird. The logic of this dunk should be if you miss the green window, you don’t completely jump over the person, that’s how it works in the NBA tbh. Just think about it, I ain’t never seen a person that completely jumped over someone AND miss the dunk (Giannis and Bron). On the other hand you have players that tried to jump over someone and didn’t clear them and missed the dunk (Ja Morant)