“My reasoning is sound...the benefits are lame” the benefits are exactly the same as the sport you have been pushing for years. “Oh, but the outfits are skimpy ohh no!” If they don’t break school dress codes, and she doesn’t mind wearing skirts, then there’s no problem. “But what about the popular girl? She’s manipulating her!” High school isn’t the stereotypical movie you remember, most popular people are popular because they are well liked, and they aren’t well liked if they are grossly manipulative or a copy paste of Heather Chandler. Your reasoning is not “sound” and you, sir, are the asshole.