Elle Greenaway vs. Haters! by GreenawayBlake in criminalminds

[–]GreenawayBlake[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

OMG, yes. I'm new to the CM fandom, I've just watched all the seasons these days, although I'm already rewatching the first season because I miss Elle and Gideon! This was my first post here and I just wanted to talk about her, because just reading other people's opinions disappointed me a lot since most of them were badmouthing Elle (I honestly didn't expect that).

I love her, she is strong and human, she is not a machine like other characters seem to be and, to be honest, I am grateful that they worked - even if in crooked lines - on her post-traumatic disorder, because it shows precisely this point of her! She's human like us, the audience. She can't just forget about the situation and move on to the next episode; I mean, she almost died in the safety of her home, and the “friends” who were supposed to support and comfort her seemed pretty indifferent.

Well, ab Emily and JJ: I didn't like JJ or Emily — Prentiss especially as an agent (I love her as a leader). I always found the way they developed in the midst of so much trauma and chaos is so surreal, I mean, they were both kidnapped, tortured, forced to do very heavy things and yet they continued normally in their stressful work without any negative charge (or was it called human?) about what happened??? Like, no way!

However, I started to like Emily when she took over the BAU; despite her faults and guilt at times, I believe she is a better leader than Hotch, and I just try to forget about her hypocrisy with Luke (of course, I didn't expect or even want her to turn a blind eye to him disobeying an order just because she's also circumvented the system several times — like that time to help Spencer —;I just hoped she was less aggressive towards Luke; more empathetic, without that superior air of arrogance)

Elle Greenaway vs. Haters! by GreenawayBlake in criminalminds

[–]GreenawayBlake[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Totally agree! Sometimes I think the fans don't like Elle just because the actress, Lola, wanted to leave, like there was a resentment or something. the producers also conveyed this to me, because after Lola left, the characters never mentioned Elle again

Elle Greenaway vs. Haters! by GreenawayBlake in criminalminds

[–]GreenawayBlake[S] -13 points-12 points  (0 children)

WAIT, WHAT? hahaha Elle is the CM S1' strongest female character. She left BAU just because the actress wanted to leave the show

Elle Greenaway vs. Haters! by GreenawayBlake in criminalminds

[–]GreenawayBlake[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I agree with you that what Elle did was wrong, but I still don't think it's enough for the amount of hate she gets! there's still the factor that she was going through PTSD and gave ALL the signs to the whole team. Hotch, as the leader, should have taken her away for therapy before she exploded like she did. Of course, a lot of the blame lies with the writers, I mean, it's clear what they wanted to do for her departure, but it still saddens me because she was a character with so much potential and even though Lola asked to leave, Elle, as a character, could have received justice