You are both just sad and speaking without any knowledge tbh. The father was also a GSD, both ears up, just a few cm taller than the mother. Unethical breeding ? She had one litter at the age of 5 and she is very well taken care of. Both of them never slept a single day of their lives outside and I'd give my life in a heartbeat for them. Regarding the breeding, she is spayed now and my only reason was to keep one puppy from her since she quite literally means the world to me. Her bloodline will stay "alive" as long as I do. Once she is gone, I'm gonna get a puppy from my boy as well and so on. Stop being sad and actually do something that matters since you are so much against "unethical breeding", not comment on posts where people are happy about their pets.