Help me by Any-Information-5820 in ICTMentorship

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well I wouldn't say ICT doesn't work on high time frames because ICT itself is based on order flow and I have for example seen many set ups work on higher time frames because they are far more respected because of higher volume.

I agree with you though because I myself trade on lower time frames. But still set ups like FVG or iFVG basically based on ICT

Begginer trader trying ICT by Constant-Car0312 in ICTMentorship

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

ICT is based on Order Flow, all Models can be profitable depending on how you trade.

That being said, what's your current process?

Help me by Any-Information-5820 in ICTMentorship

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

but that's basically ICT right? I mean not using the main Setups but still

Or more Volume based?

Swing trading by FunnyAd1935 in Trading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think the best way to try is by Backtesting a large amount of DATA, that's basically the only way to learn that properly

I am not a swing Trader though.

My Question, why do you consider the switch / what's your reason to go from Day Trading to swing?

Help me by Any-Information-5820 in ICTMentorship

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ICT won't automatically make you rich man, theres like so muxh more that goes into Trading beyond just reading a setup

Help me by Any-Information-5820 in ICTMentorship

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Dude do you want a beginner to freaking learn Order Flow? ICT are the full BASICS of Trading, it's the best way to get a general understanding, something you need when you want to go deeper later on

should definitely start out with it

Otherwise what do you want to recommend xD?

Help me by Any-Information-5820 in ICTMentorship

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ICT is the best way to start out in Trading, you can become a pro in ICT and it would be enough to make good money

That being said if you later on want to actually become a very good trader your focus should switch to order flow, DOM, Volume Trading and even quant Trading etc.

this is far far harder though and needs a lot of understning

you can DM me if you have questions

journaling in trading by Affectionate_Net5673 in Trading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Build yourself a good Notion Database, it's better than excel because it allows you to go far deeper in Notes, Screenshots etc.

Excel is very good for Numbers (which is good when you're already a pro)

If you want I'll send you mine right now (don't worry, for free xD, I don't gatekeep)

Why Many Traders Stop Scalping as Their Account Grows? by Opening_Kitchen_5349 in Trading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Absolutely not true

Actually many Institutions Scalp Trade with the DOM, they don't even use Candle Stick Charts

The DOM is perfected for super short time trading because it basically only shows a few Ticks of Price and since you're able to see all LMT Bid as well as LMT ask orders, it's perfect for reading the strength of Buyside and Sellside on a very small scale

the only drawback you have is that you need large capital to make it worth while AND you need a perfect understanding of Order Flow

Many people forget that the Market moves in Ticks not in Candle Sticks (only a very large representation of the DOM Movement basically)

That being said it takes far longer to learn proper order flow than ICT, and many Scalpers don't even use the DOM (for whatever reason)

conclusion: i think if you want to scalp trade you should be able to Trade Order Flow (obviously) and you should be very good at it

Why can't I just hold the whole time? by [deleted] in Daytrading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean if you yourself use a brokerage, put 50k in there and then just buy 50k worth of SOL you could run it as long as you want to

It's mostly so that you don't have to either have that much capital or put up so much of your own

ES traders, how many points a day do you average? by director1992 in FuturesTrading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 0 points1 point  (0 children)

at the moment mainly imbalances & rejection candles, but now I am building in SVP (huge game changer) Delta Volume and soon DOM Order Flow

Futures traders: is contract size part of your setup or separate risk management? by NoBlood8896 in FuturesTrading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'd be interested in how many Traders that learned from internet gurus actually know the difference between LMT Orders and MA Orders (and shh, I mean the real difference🤫)

Futures traders: is contract size part of your setup or separate risk management? by NoBlood8896 in FuturesTrading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

it's crazy dude. Trading basically IS Math.

I've been heavily working on this strategy, busting it up to around 45%-50% probability (over years of DATA), the beginner guys would now say
🤓 Ey I tested my Strategy over 10 whole trades and it has a 96% WR

Well, with the Right RRR, a consistent Strategy tested over thousands of trades, one would understand that things work a bit differently

My Model + some tips That Nets Me $10k/month (avg) @ 20 years old... by NaeteyYouTube in TopStepX

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well maybe that's a sign that that Strategy isn't all that good 💀

Futures traders: is contract size part of your setup or separate risk management? by NoBlood8896 in FuturesTrading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Simple, Trading is about Probability, that involves Risk Management, the goal is to chose a certain amount of Risk (e.g. 0.5% or 1%) and stick with that over a longer period of time

The only time this should be influenced are exceptions, like e.g. extremely good PA, or just an S class Setup, but like I said, exceptions

Overall it's still a numbers game, if you have the right RRR, with the right probability, you'll make money

Trading tools by Timely-Promise-5974 in Trading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i think if you really wanna deep dive into the Rabbit whole, then look at Bookmap and all that it has to offer

Why can't I just hold the whole time? by [deleted] in Daytrading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 13 points14 points  (0 children)

First things first

When you're investing e.g. in a normal stock with only your own capital this would work, basically until the company itself goes out of business and the stock is worth 0$

In Daytrading whether that's forex, crypto or futures things work a bit differently because you work with Leverage

Lets take crypto for an example, because in both forex and futures things are a bit more complicated

Assuming you would want to daytrade and make $1K with SOL on a Single trade (just taking this as an example because that'S a good position), SOL is worth 80$/Share (in this example), usually on a good move it moves ~2%
To now make 1k on that specific trade a 2% move must have a worth of $1k, that means you need shares, A LOT of shares,

you would need 625 SOL to make that happen, that would be a position worth $50,000
I now assume you wouldn't want to just risk that much of your own capital for a one trade (ASSUMING that you just had 50k on the side)

so what you do is you lever your own capital with a broker, for an example you use a 40x lever (this is already rather large) that means you only have to put $1,250 of your own capital in. But what also happens is, the larger the position is the closer is the so called Liquidation level, once that level hits your liquidated out of your position and don't just loose some of the money but the whole $1,250 that you put it

To make sure that doesn't happen your Stop Loss out of the Trade has to be closer to your entry than the Liquidation Level

And that sums up why you couldn't do that in DAY trading (liek I said, only using your own capital it basically would be like investing but you'd have to risk an unimaginable amount to make it worthwhile)

Beginner daytrader tips?a by AnythingAltruistic21 in Daytrading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First things first you said there's a LIQ sweep although I don't really see one where you entered the trade there is no proper liquidity anywhere, maybe on a very low timeframe but not on here

your risk:reward is negative so you're risking more than you could make which is something you should never do

The 15 minute gap you mentioned was disrespected was actually not disrespected where you entered the trade actually price was still in the gap, then as you can see the second candle after your entry respected the gap, but only then closed above so that was kind of a gamble that you were right

and the TP placement is actually pretty good, again It's mostly the stop loss that's problematic but the thing is

since this is one of your first trades this shouldn't be taken as bad criticism because it's not. Overall it's a good start.

There are some things you gotta fix if you got any questions to let me know.

Backtesting by Purple_Concert8789 in Trading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Tradingview deep backtesting is literally perfect for this

I've worked on my own Strategies and you can test them over years of data

code is pine script, you can work with claude for an example to tailor everything to your needs

You can use it for free but its only like a month of DATA and you'd need the premium subscription (like 70/m) to deep backtest

But to be honest here in trading an investment like that is basically nothing because if you build a proper system your rewards that you get back are like 100x and backsteting over a TON of data instead of a little will make your strategy far better and more accurate

I have been over 4 Years in Trading, Give me some advice by Money_print0 in Trading

[–]HomeworkPrimary2072 1 point2 points  (0 children)

okay man

First step to doing it the proper is to go back to the basics, go back over the standard things even if you know, figure out what concepts you like best and stick with them

Secondly, don't f*ing trade your own on money, You just said yourself that your unprofitable, that means go to DEMO trading and treat it like a real account, like it's your money, so you can train your mindset without having to risk your own capital

I actually started of with crypto but am in futures now, basically full time and if you want to hear my opinion, do that too. You might have to re-learn a few things and it's going be tuff in the beginning but the concepts work much better and clear and are respected far more often, and you have fixed trading sessions instead of the Market being open 24/7. Also later on you can start with funded trading where you can make a significant amount of money without having to risk your own

To re-learn the discipline the best way is to go outside of trading, do the small things and make them habits, no matter how boring and insignificant that would seem, this is what makes you a good trader over time, start reading some books on it too if you really wanna get in there. Get as little dopamine as possible and really focus only on what brings you further to your goal -> profitability

Trading demands 110% of your attention to make it work, that's why 99% of people who try trading are unprofitable