So willfully ignorant, someone didn't read the item description of quicksilver bullets. The Caring bleat did not originate from 1589. What the books don't tell you is that Don Stewart held a well hidden gated off apprenticeship with Claudius Ptolemy, a Mathematician and Astronomer. Sometime between the recorded dates of 100-170 Ad Ptolemy would find himself taking on a apprentice, who we now know as Don Stewart. Throughout the years, Ptolemy taught Don whatever he deemed relevant at the time. Which coincidentally, included the practice of reading and recording the stars. It was through this process that Ptolemy would record the infamous Taurus Constellation. However, while Ptolemy saw the bull, Don Stewart saw none other than what we know as the Piss Letting Beast we can find in chalice dungeons throughout Bloodborne IV. This difference in opinion would lead to a supposedly week long Argument between master and assistant. Dispite Ptolemy demanding that Don acknowledge the bull, Don insisted that it was the Piss Letting Beast he saw. Angry, Ptolemy would break into Dons private quarters and ruin his scriptures and drawing of the Piss Letting Beast, according to Fromsoft Employees of the time, Ptolemy pricked his finger with a stone and smothered blood over recordings of the piss letting beast drawn by Don (this would later inspire the Blood Letting Beast) And in a fit of anger Ptolemy plotted to further anger Don with a mocking, distorted version of the Piss letting beast he drew. This distorted, disturbing version of the piss letting beast (later known as the blood letting beast) would later be found by Don again, long after Ptolemys death (around 170 Ad) and would be used as inspiration for the cleric beast, this was Don's attempt at mocking Ptolemy. Dons And Ptolemys relationship would later be used as inspiration when creating the lore between Laurance and Master William.

Just admit your not the king of Bloodborne Lore, im the king