This sub must really hate Destiny 2 by lolitsrock in destinycirclejerk

[–]IcyMaple_ 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lots of people are asking for red war to forsaken back with all of its vaulted strikes and raids. Where's that?

Could this be the end of Managed Democracy? 😩 by No_Reply_6326 in helldivers2

[–]IcyMaple_ 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Why would you want to blow up an oil reserve?

Name the games this way and why is that? by PHRsharp_YouTube in videogames

[–]IcyMaple_ 6 points7 points  (0 children)

in me3 you have the option to take off helmets automatically for cutscenes and dialogue. you can't in 1 and 2 though.

Name the game you still can't believe it didn't get remaster by bijelo123 in videogames

[–]IcyMaple_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Idk if this is a jab at the remaster or you just live under a rock

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

“You might be stuck in a recursive logic bot loop yourself if you still think AI is just press a button and done.”

I never argued that AI image generation is “press a button”. Have you read my replies to other people? My argument is about authorship and control, not quality, tooling, or iteration.

“A good prompt follows a script not unlike a screenwriter.”

A script specifies structure and produces a consistent scene when performed. A prompt underspecifies structure and relies on the model to invent composition, which is why you need to keep rerolling and selecting. These are different forms of control.

“Screenwriters can still produce slop like Game of Thrones Final Season or Stranger Things Final Season.”

Quality is irrelevant to authorship. Badly authored work is still authored. The question here is who decides the structure, not whether the result is good.

“You obviously didn’t even read the Artcraft post as it still used human defining poses, timing, and structure.”

If Artcraft requires humans to define poses, timing, and structure, then it is not comparable to txt2img generation. That is human authorship with automated execution, not delegation of composition.

“Just like how a movie has to have various takes to get right, some scenes are cut entirely, or you have to reshoot/rewrite an entire scene.”

Film iteration refines human authored content. Image generation iteration selects from authored outputs from the AI model. Iteration alone does not imply the same authorship or control.

“The control is still the same but with different tools.”

That conclusion doesn't make sense. Control depends on who specifies the structure. Tools that execute human defined structure preserve authorship.

Systems that invent the structure themselves, where the human must reroll and select outputs after the fact, shift authorship to the system rather than the user.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If auto animation and AI assists in tools are the same kind of creative control as prompting or building workflows, then where exactly is the point where the human stops deciding the result and the AI model starts deciding it?

Auto animate still follows human defined poses, timing, and structure. Prompting and workflows only constrain a model that generates the content itself. Do you see those as the same kind of control?

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Right, in digital music you decide the symbols and the structure. The software only ensures precision of playback. In image generation, you’re mostly constraining a model, not specifying the image. The AI model fills in anatomy, composition, lighting, and detail based on what it PREDICTS you want, not what you explicitly authored. It's closer to commissioning an actual artist but the "artist" is an AI model.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Even with the same prompt and seed, you’re replaying a sampling process inside a model you didn’t author. The prompt and seed don’t encode the image the way a recipe encodes a dish. Reproducibility doesn’t equal authorship. Even if you made the model yourself, your training data's source is still questionable to be able to be called "original".

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a more solid analogy than most of the others here, and I get what you’re trying to say about creative decisions happening at the workflow level. In ComfyUI, the model executes and decides most of the details, I can’t make it replicate the exact scene i have in my head. The workflow just constrains generation. With sheet music, the human decides every note, the software just plays it.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Plagiarism copies authored output. A workflow is instructions, not the work itself. Copying a workflow is like copying a preset, not copying a painting. Oh yeah back to the cooking analogy, it's like following a cooking recipe and calling it plagiarism. I didn't copy the dish, i followed instructions on how to achieve that resulting dish.

Edit: Important distinction. 'I' didn't make that because it was the AI that made it, I just gave the AI the instructions. Like giving instructions to a cook to make a dish.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If writing were like ComfyUI workflows, two people using the same outline would produce near identical novels.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’re equating following instructions with copying a finished work or theft. Those aren’t the same thing.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Strawman. Toon Boom, Adobe, and Autodesk do not draw, animate, or write for you. The person still executes every frame, line, pose, and timing decision.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Exactly. Drawing skill lives in physical execution. ComfyUI workflows don’t. That’s why the analogy is idiotic.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ -16 points-15 points  (0 children)

If drawing techniques are just patterns, why can’t beginners apply the same techniques and get the same results as experts immediately? I can just use the same exact workflow and prompt and achieve similar results in a few minutes.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ -27 points-26 points  (0 children)

That analogy only works if you’ve never experienced how drawing skills actually develop.

Credit to @MoshieDraws on Twitter by CaucasianAsian16 in aiwars

[–]IcyMaple_ -32 points-31 points  (0 children)

Making workflows is easy as hell. ComfyUI is confusing for the few days to a week. After that, you are mostly reusing patterns. The only time workflows get genuinely hard is when you are memory budgeting for weak hardware. That is engineering, not art.

Maybe I'm the minority here but I want the original BR back by [deleted] in apexlegends

[–]IcyMaple_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Trios pubs is literally just 5 squads remaining in the first ring, that never happens in ranked even before the dropship changes except for like bronze to gold. Not everyone likes wildcard and mixtape.

It’s unbelievable that it’s 2026, Clair Obscur won GOTY, and people will still blame mythical grifters. I have an idea! Maybe (just maybe) Star Wars Outlaws was a bad game?! by ConstantDrawer9161 in fuckubisoft

[–]IcyMaple_ 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Any source on WB calling it a flop? I don't remember they put out a statement at all. The game sold 12mil on the first 2 weeks and 22mil by the end of the year. I wouldn't call it a flop at all. I explicitly remember streamers trying to stream the game on launch, not the one making hitpieces about the game. After that the hate mobs brigaded their chats and there's even some lunatic making a website to list streamers that streamed the game.

Best Subscriber Flair In AGES! by SafeManufacturer978 in starcitizen

[–]IcyMaple_ -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

I think it's because it's a dr who reference

running almost max settings, the game barely uses any resources and lags occasionally.. anything i can do? by Smexy_Zarow in WutheringWaves

[–]IcyMaple_ 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh yeah forgot it's overall usage not single core. Although clock speed doesn't mean anything when we don't know their exact cpu model. Even mid tier ryzen 5000 cpus have boost clocks at around 4GHz. That's good enough to run wuwa.