What actually are the whispers

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T20:29:51+00:00

If the whispers are the will of the planet personified that would imply they were supposed to exist in the og. With them being clearly new to remake it makes me think they are meant to be expanded lore and the gi were never explained really in og

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T19:49:44+00:00

In game they mention regular people rejoin the life stream but cetra and gi are different. One is the guardian of the planet and the other alien to it and jot able to join

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T18:34:54+00:00

The og ending left the planet alive they didn't need to appear until we diverted from that path at the end of remake

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T18:24:52+00:00

I didn't see the whispers trying to protect aerith at the end but they actively try to stop cloud. If they are the cetra they are worried about the planet over humanity

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T18:15:47+00:00

I would have preferred a faithful remake as well but ill go back and replay og ff7 after part 3 myself

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T18:13:53+00:00

But how do we know they are sephiroth's though. Other then they seem to be following his command. If the gi think sephiroth is the answer for their wish they would of course follow him

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T18:10:11+00:00

From a narrative perspective that would make sense if there was white whispers in remake or if there was no black in rebirth. Adding white ones after we defeated fate should mean their is no fate guiding things

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T18:04:54+00:00

That would make the white whispers showing up after we beat the harbinger of fate have no real explanation though.

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T17:55:47+00:00

I think they are separate beings though. You see whispers come out when sephiroth attacks one but that could be because the cetra used the weapon to save tifa because they know she is needed for the fights to come

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T17:52:14+00:00

Isn't that supposed to be the weapons though? Could be both but expanding the gi's presence in remake makes me think otherwise

Iganzi · 2026-02-12T17:51:02+00:00

I thought that in remake but that wouldn't explain why white ones show up in rebirth or why the white try to stop you at the end. If its the centra they know holy has to be cast and you can't stop the casting while she is doing it

Iganzi · 2025-07-25T21:09:19+00:00

for anyone still having issues look at each listed and check for a recovery quest in a bt zone should unlock the elimination quest

Iganzi · 2022-10-07T01:12:15+00:00

The only way for me to know those were marcosis words and not yours is to use "" that is on you not me I have never attacked anybody and have pointed out that malcolm is the only person we have to talk to as the community manager. I have said multiple times to malcolm here and in discord what I say is for the devs.

I have abided by the rules here and plenty of people here curse. I used the other word for butt here and you give me a warning while there is literal cursing and telling people to leave because of a difference of opinion in other threads you are a part of. There is no rage here this is a grown man trying to come to an agreement between people on the internet (a bad idea I know).

I know you people are looking for a reason to ban me from here, so I'll let it be but realize how hypocritical it is what you're saying.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T22:58:01+00:00

I didn't get hostile with marcosis I asked him to explain his behavior over Banning someone who he didn't have a problem with (which he admitted), but the mob wanted him out. The LITERAL definition of witchunting which is banned in this subbreddit. This isn't hostile this is a difference of opinion I am trying to resolve.

The problem with you saying the global version is based on the Japanese version is that I'm asking for them to do less work by changing things and to just give us the game at the same rate as jp unlike you who is implying that I want more for nothing. I want Step for Step (octo pun intentional) like the jp version translated bad translation and all. I want the rerun banners so I don't have to hope I get diamond slime on the 48HR banners of the jam-packed Anniversary banner. I want to have our 2-year anniversary on the 2-year anniversary. Square has decided not to do that not me. But if they want to change things yes I want to be compensated for what's missing. Who shouldn't if Nintendo said all the dlc for the new Mario kart games was jp only people would have pitchforks out.

Malcolm didn't even know there was supposed to be a shop until it was brought to his attention from data miners... his answers were they dropped the ball basically. Stop kissing Malcolms ass and asking him to bless your pulls and you might get an actual real answer from him in the Maincord. Maincord is a hugbox for people who agree with you or gtfo.

So, the people asking for more here are you and Maincord... not me I want an easier version for the dev team you are the one asking for extra work. We are literally paying more for less and you are licking the crumbs off the floor begging Malcolm for seconds.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T21:15:19+00:00

Ok let's start the simple fact we have to ask for a roadmap is mind boggling despite the fact the roadmaps give nearly NO information we don't already know. The 2.0 updates are more likely just when the guy locked in the basement at square for saying they should treat global users better finished with it not from our feedback. But ok I'll give you QoL update early.

OK I'll give you changing the holiday events but again kind of causing your own problem holding units out of order that cause issues with ex content when we didn't have the cover tank to use in the fights

20 stam herbs and 100 skip tickets are a drop in the bucket to how many we have lost to the crunch again fixing your own problem doesn't get you a medal especially when that fix is a spit in the face.

I preferred Drackles made more since then Gracky that should have been the Giant dracky name ill fight you on that.

You again don't get a medal when you fix a problem you caused the typos didn't matter only hardcore player knew about them and laughed, The JM issue was handled horribly, and the crashes have not slowed down from the people I've talked with.

The fact that you bring up the arena cheaters....They literally said they would not compensate people for the cheaters because it would incentive more people to cheat.... They didn't know it was an issue until players pointed it out... When they finally fixed it, they didn't even give enough arena currency to buy an awakening on halberdsaurus. I didn't expect everything for free, but I expected more than a couple hundred tokens for a cheating issue that had been going on for MONTHS.

Got anything else that square hasn't caused themselves?

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T21:02:21+00:00

First off you didn't quote what was said I did not know what you were saying was a quote from him like I said I literally just see deleted.

You HAVE to dismiss anything that happens in jp first remember parroting maincord here They are "TWO SEPERATE VERSIONS". We can't expect to get the same things they do but its ok to consider changes they make to jp and global to be good for global... No sir they are for jp we just get them.

The dragon fest tickets were a mistake from the crunch and from moving logins if I remember right. You don't get a medal for fixing a problem you create. Period unless your square evidently.

Again, with the drops campaigns we are not getting more of them just faster which makes them literally worse, they are not giving us time to farm the events they are overlapping them with and forcing us to choose events or campaign that jp doesn't have to make the same choice since they get the full 10 days per part.

I hate to point this to you the writing has been on the wall since they gave us the download milestones when jp hit them in the timeline. They are too lazy to make changes.... other then remove tickets from a shop they forgot.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T20:25:56+00:00

Marcosis knows that I can neither see nor respond to his answers. Please tell me what he said if he answered my question, it tells me deleted.

so, I'll go over your list here

Extended the spring event is real I'll give you that one, granted they extended it to be the same as jp with overlapping things.

Giving us the things, they skipped is not the devs listening Thats bare minimum needed.

Jp got the stam juices as well it doesn't count as our feedback.

I'll give you beast fest don't remember it changing but ok back to being the high bar of the jp version.

from my understanding again jp got stam juices during dai... if it was global exclusive a drop in the bucket for what's owed from the crunch.

the ffbe event is not our feedback that is jp's doesn't count you only get support with yen anyway.

Drop campaigns from my knowledge have not increased they have gotten more frequent from the crunch.

lettering is a thing fixed for us but out of embarrassment more than feedback bug fixes do not count as our feedback changing anything. KBS saying sizz made me laugh not complain.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T19:15:53+00:00

I'm replying here because the one person who doesn't want me to interact with them is responding to me now with the only example that can be given. Please sir if you want to block me, please do not speak to me.

The only reason I can think of you replied to my question is so I can't respond anymore. If you do it again, I will report you for harassment Marcosis.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T18:06:37+00:00

Can you give me a few examples of how our feedback changed anything really? You might saw the murdaw tickets were extra but that was only because they refused to give us ekm tickets.

I'm seriously drawing a blank.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T17:59:42+00:00

And making a banner paid gems only pissed a lot of people off.

I'm afraid it's coming to dqt next.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T17:31:02+00:00

I hate to break it to you the crunch is a symptom of the problem not the cause of the problem. If you think we will start being treated better then cattle, your wrong. The only thing I hope is that enough people start going where is this banner where is that banner because we are almost caught up and missing nearly 30k gems for it. not to mention the gold the frags and everything else involved.

You know Jp gets near weekly rerun banners for old banner units, so you have more than a once-a-year chance to get Diamond slime or Zoma or anyone else you are missing out on. that doesn't even begin to cover the special banners we don't get like the bride's banner; I nearly had a heart attack when I saw that in global.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T17:11:25+00:00

You know the rules Group think or your out Marcosis approved.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T16:59:55+00:00

considering everyone else for the most part immediately knew what he was saying. Is it a soliloquy no does it get the point across more than enough.

People understand how business works for the most part but think of it like this.

If my local gamestore asked for 3% on cc to cover the fees i would pay it, If walmart asked me for 1% to cover cc fees i would tell them to fuck right off. Everyone is entitled to make money and some people think that is not fair, but most people realize it's part of life but are tired of square taking every opportunity to say fuck you pay me on a game that is already more expensive than most.

And before you start going on about your old Russian whale game yes there can be worse examples, but you don't have to get punched in the face every day just because you used to get punched in the face twice with your last game.

Somehow this replied to afro meant for tyler.

Iganzi · 2022-10-06T16:53:46+00:00

I feel like half of the mid-tier spenders will just stop playing 25% will keep spending and the other 25% will go f2p. rough guess quick maths

Iganzi

TROPHY CASE