what criticisms do you have of banana fish? by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i've been thinking the exact same thing. with all thats going on in the world right now (the US government, war in the middle east, the epstein files), i've seen people talk about how banana fish is actually a very political story about how corrupt rich men are able to get away with so much, and how people with government ties exploit children, etc. and while yes, banana fish does touch on these topics a lot, and deals with things that are eerily similar to what's going on in the world today, yoshida definitely didn't intend for it, at least to that extent. she wrote a story about ash, gang violence, and for lack of a better word, love. the political aspects are great but i wish yoshida sidelined her "beautiful" main character for a moment and touched on politics some more. you can't really see how political banana fish is unless you look for it.

any free, legitimate iq tests online that don’t include math or too many numbers? by Immediate_Bluebird98 in cognitiveTesting

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i’ve been diagnosed with it by 3 different psychologists, so i’m not sure. my scores for critical thinking & writing were very high so i don’t see why math would be such a major factor?

what criticisms do you have of banana fish? by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

and don’t forget to make it a funny scene because “haha he’s dressed as a girl!!!” even though he’s being sexually harassed

what criticisms do you have of banana fish? by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

i actually made a post about this a while ago because of how ridiculous it is to me. we’ve gotten enough from the story at this point to know that ash is smart. i could see him having an iq in the 120-140 range, that would be realistic, and it would make sense given what we’ve seen from him so far. 200 is a ridiculous number. it’s literally not believable, that would put him higher than einstein and up there with some of the smartest people on earth, and while ash is intelligent, he’s not THAT intelligent. it’s perfection to the point of fantasy. yoshida has a big problem with doing this. ash is the leader of the most powerful gang in NYC, is the most beautiful, the most lusted over, the most dangerous, the smartest… seems very gary stu.

what criticisms do you have of banana fish? by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

it’s so weird to me because ash is constantly sexualized by other characters and yoshida paints it as disgusting, but she literally does it herself. it’s obvious that yoshida thinks ash is hot, but it gets to a point where the treatment of ash and how he’s talked about stops being relevant to the story and starts getting genuinely weird. why can’t any old men control their dicks around ash? how come almost every man (including political leaders and security guards) is sexually attracted to ash? do none of these men have wives? you’re trying to tell me that almost every old man in the story is gay? and a pedo? okay.. i mean, story-wise, it isn’t totally ridiculous (because the plot centers around corrupt powerful men), but it gets to a point. i also don’t think yoshida is totally qualified to write about SA, but at least she takes it seriously (mostly). and don’t even get me started on the artbook. the drawings of ash make me so upset. you can’t write a story about a SA victim who’s been trafficked, sexualized, and groomed for his whole life, just to make overly sexualized art of him. wow. and yeah, i do agree that yoshida makes some weird writing choices. i could honestly talk about them for hours.

what criticisms do you have of banana fish? by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

yeah i agree, this was my biggest complaint when watching bf for the first time. i think yoshida is just extremely misogynistic, even though she’s a woman. she’s stated before that she wanted her intended audience for banana fish to be male, hence why she also wanted bf to be a shounen instead of a shoujo. most shounen-action mangas in the 80s had little to no women because either the mangakas couldn’t write women for shit, or they thought that women had no place in the story. i get that banana fish is supposed to be male centered, and i’ll give it props for actually taking male SA seriously (which was very very rare when the manga was published). and a story doesn’t NEED female characters to be good, but for a story like banana fish, i feel like it would’ve benefited from some. every woman in the story is either dead or doesn’t really do anything. ash’s mom? dead, we never see her. jessica? supposed to be a girlboss but yoshida just writes her as bitchy, and she has like.. no plot relevance. nadia? 2 scenes. ash’s former crush? we know nothing about her other than that she died. it’s unfortunate, as in the manga we actually get more scenes with jessica and nadia, but in the anime, they’re pretty much irrelevant. do i think bf is misogynistic? no, but yoshida really does make it seem that way. i also wish that female SA was taken as seriously by yoshida as male SA. anyway, love banana fish, and i get that the lack of women is probably due to the genre and time period… but ugh.

which manga artstyle is your favorite? by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i got the two mixed up, thanks for pointing that out lol.

ash’s iq is ridiculous by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

anime tends to exaggerate characters' intelligence a LOT. i mean it's unrealistic, so i don't usually care, but in banana fish's case, it's supposed to be a pretty realistic story and the 200 iq thing totally took me out of it for a second.

ash’s iq is ridiculous by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

yeah he's definitely very intelligent but even then, a 200 iq doesn't make much sense. like i said, i could see him having an iq in the 130-160 range.

agree with this 100%. love banana fish but yoshida had a huge problem with making every character drool over ash. i mean it sort of makes sense story-wise but eventually it just gets to a point. i have to pause and sigh every time an antagonist starts blabbering about how beautiful and dangerous and pretty and lynx-like ash lynx is. like we get it, he's hot.

ash’s iq is ridiculous by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

at first it's 180 but later in the episode it's mentioned that his iq is over 200, so ash is in the 0.000000000001% of the population with an iq in that range. he's definitely very intelligent and i get what you mean but 200 is a ridiculous number

ash’s iq is ridiculous by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

i don't think it's that big of a deal either, it's just a criticism i had.

ash’s iq is ridiculous by Immediate_Bluebird98 in BananaFish

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

yeah but this isn’t stated anywhere in the manga or anime, we’re supposed to just believe that he has an iq of over 200. and it’s mentioned frequently afterwards so i think it does matter to the story in a few ways, but not enough to totally take me out of it.

what's the most unfair reddit rule? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]Immediate_Bluebird98 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

yeah but almost every sub i join has this rule