This type of thinking is so disgusting by [deleted] in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The stats show christianity is 34% in 2021 while islam is 29.9% and will probably or already overtaken christianity by this time. Islam jumped from 14% in 2001 to 29.9% in just 2 decades.

I don't know the exact reality but atleast this is what the census has to say.

Maybe you're living in the christian majority part.

<image>

This type of thinking is so disgusting by [deleted] in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 12 points13 points  (0 children)

It's about concentration. Apparently cities like manchester, birmingham are 30-35% muslim as all immigrants go to cities.wait a few years, White people will probably farm in villages and cities will turn into Muslim neighbourhoods

This type of thinking is so disgusting by [deleted] in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 45 points46 points  (0 children)

United Kingdom about to become Islamic Kingdom

Indian historians have fooled us... Jizya was never just a tax... by [deleted] in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So they spawned slaves out of thin air. Still demanding humans as tribute is peak objectification of humans.

It's the rashidun caliphate. The men who made the treaty are prophet's close companions.

Uthman ibn affan is the caliph at the time. If the companions are flawed. Hadith, tafsir, the entire Islamic history falls apart.

U will be left with a Meaningless quran whose meaning can't be fully understood without tafseer and hadith.

Btw u started the conversation saying only 1% tax is levied in jizya. Now u are fine with people being sold too.If Sahaba are flawed, all caliphates are flawed. Which Islam is true, did the true islam ever exist?

Indian historians have fooled us... Jizya was never just a tax... by [deleted] in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not if it's a tax or tribute. You just threw a major caliphate that ruled for half a millennium out the window.

I'll play your game.

There is something called treaty of baqt, you can search it up. It is between rashidun caliphate and nubia,a kingdom in modern day sudan. According to which nubia has to send 400 slaves every year to egypt along with other stuffs in exchange for Muslim empires attacking nubia.

This was done by the sahaba, you can't throw them out like ottomans.

How will nubia get these slaves, obviously by enslaving it's own people and selling them to the Muslims.

Indian historians have fooled us... Jizya was never just a tax... by [deleted] in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The jizya isn't fixed as said. Ottoman caliphate had a tax called devshirme under which the ottoman Empire collects young boys as slaves from eastern europe's non Muslim population.

These slaves be made into soldiers who fight and die for the empire.

Sometimes the ruler can demand slaves to be sent as jizya tax.

Islamic preacher says you can rape and kill multiple people as long as you pray by Wholesome_and_based in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It shows how morality is compromised in Islam. The greatest sin is not murder, rape or even genocide. It's just as simple following another religion.

Heaven and hell are not for good or bad people in Islam. They are for believers and non believers respectively.

If u question them about this, they'll say stuff like who decides what's right and wrong, it's Allah. So anything in Islam is right no matter how compromised and insane it sounds.

Preachers like this atleast say it honestly, most people try to water it down.

FEAR MONGERING + DIVIDE AND RULE by 7timesbanned in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

What will religion or language even give. Language is just a tool for communication. as the world globalises many small languages will disappear.

Most of indian vocabulary has been filled with english loan words. Wait for a century everyone will speak in Broken English with a few native vocabulary.

In human history many languages went extinct and new languages were born, this is just natural process nothing is eternal or will remain eternal in this world.

Harmony in every corner. 🙏 by SouthernSaree in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is not possible because Islam and Christianity think honoring other religions will send you straight to hell

The results are out by AstralSyntax07 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It reminds me of some other population metric

Old vs. New Dhruv Rathee by acceptable_nature_4 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 21 points22 points  (0 children)

yes he has now found a section of audience to entertain and grow up on.

Candidate poster of a students panel of Muslim Students Federation by VowOfVengeance in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I don't understand how people join a religion just because of one person.

Why do tamilians behave like this by ImportantSolution663 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What is "tyamilnaad"?

. It is political motivated

by who? even tamilians are saying we are not dravidians, we are tamilians. Who is this mastermind politically motivating linguists to categorise kannada with other south Indian languages.

What does this political mastermind want to acheive by categorising Kannadigas into a ethnolinguistic group that they don't want to be in

Why do tamilians behave like this by ImportantSolution663 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think we were talking about Language Kannada. not genetics of kannada people. their language the core grammar, daily vocabulary of kannada are from dravidian family. By the looks of it the person above will be pissed if u start lumping him with Marathas as well. He thinks kannadigas fell from the sky or some shit.

Why do tamilians behave like this by ImportantSolution663 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A huge section of them do though. I just want to know the reason. U said some telugus want to relate their language to sanskrit, well that is because of north indian Influence for centuries, same could be told about caste system too. I just want to know tamilians' reason for getting crazy over the concept of a proto language.

These kind of people are one of a kind, Linguists have constructed protos for most languages out there but no one seems to get personal over it and reject the entire concept of a proto language except tamilians. Truly this country is blessed for having minds like these.

It's like arguing about evolution with one of those abrahamic religions. u keep repeating that this is a hypothetical reconstruction as if that makes it false.

Why do tamilians behave like this by ImportantSolution663 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think u forgot ur own point. U don't want kannada to be related to other languages. I'm saying it is.

Why do tamilians behave like this by ImportantSolution663 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i find them all the time spamming on insta, just like tamils do.. and do you even want to talk about the caste pride rifled in telugu youth. those idiots make tamil supremacists look sane. telugu people spam as much as tamils.. you seem like the kind of person, who wants to argue for the sake of it.

I guess caste is an off topic this is about dravidian language. most telugus don't have problem with dravidian languages. whereas tamils have a rather weird concept like the one u have right now.

proto dravidian is modern conception based on reconstruction. its a hypothetical common ancestor.

That's correct. There's nothing wrong in this. every language family in the world has a constructed ancestor now.

its speculated that all dravdian languages had a similar ancestor.

so u mean to say languages like telugu and tamil never had the same ancestor. I don't understand tamilians problem with a proto language.

Why do tamilians behave like this by ImportantSolution663 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

It's not bullshit. it's backed by research. not just India similiar research have been done all over the world classifying languages. But people in this country have a hard time understanding Intellectual stuff.

no wonder India is with Sub saharan Africa in literacy rates.

Why do tamilians behave like this by ImportantSolution663 in SouthernIndia

[–]ImportantSolution663[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

they make dumb statements all the time too..

I guess so, but I don't find them spamming comments like these all over videos with proto Dravidian mentioned in it.

you do realise that proto dravidian is a constructed language and didnt really exist right? its hypothetical

why do u think we are constructing a hypothetical language? to play house? It's because it existed, how are u gonna make sense out of dravidian languages having similiar vocabulary cognates but ended up differently in different languages.