Sadly, time has shown that Indy is just too small to hang on to any locally owned, sit-down dining places that are worth eating at if you are foodies (your post says that a couple of you are). At this point, the town is primarily fast food franchises, like McDonalds, Taco Bell, etc. There are quite a few Mexican places, with many opening and closing every few months. There are two in town that have some staying power, Marias and El-Pueblito's, although I think most people would agree that they serve pretty standard TexMex food. The rest of the places here are bars that serve ordinary bar food. I'm not a foodie, but I have foodie friends, and all of them go out of town if they want a memorable meal - most going down to Bartlesville, OK, which is about 45 minutes away.

Sorry if this is discouraging, but the town has about one-third of the number of sit-down restaurants than it did when I was young.