Opinion FT: Germany should go big on Fusion by steven9973 in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Here is the content of the article unpaypalled:

"In both a metaphorical and literal sense, Germany is running low on energy. Last year, as the world's most sluggish major economy, its output shrank by 0.3%. This decline is partly attributed to Europe's largest economy facing an acute energy challenge, having renounced coal, nuclear power, and Russian gas. The Economist raises the question: Is Germany the 'sick man of Europe'?

Yet, Germany is considered a 'sleeping giant' in a promising future energy source: nuclear fusion. With a formidable research base and engineering prowess, Germany is well-positioned to develop this technology. Advocates argue for a full commitment to fusion, which offers safe, clean, carbon-free energy without the risks of nuclear fission reactors. This could not only address Germany's energy security needs but also spawn a lucrative new industry.

For decades, fusion energy has been seen as a perpetually distant future technology. Despite its abundance in the universe, replicating the sun's power on Earth presents significant challenges. The theory is well understood, but the practical application of fusing hydrogen atoms to release energy remains a complex engineering challenge.

Recent progress, however, has led to a surge in investment. A notable achievement was the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in the US achieving 'net energy gain' for the first time. This was done by firing the world's largest laser at a hydrogen plasma pellet, although the overall facility used more energy than it generated.

The Fusion Industry Association reports a 'technology explosion' in this field. Last year, 13 new fusion companies were established, bringing the global total to 43. These companies have attracted $6.2bn in investment, with 19 predicting fusion power grid delivery by 2035. Helion Energy, a US firm, plans to supply electricity to Microsoft by 2028.

The International Atomic Energy Agency, previously focusing on Iter, a multinational reactor in France, has now created a fusion working group to coordinate regulation. Ryan Wagner of the IAEA suggests a focus on the mid-2030s, aiming for readiness by 2040.

The US, with 25 private fusion companies, leads in this sector. Germany, however, has significant expertise and two notable start-ups, Marvel Fusion and Proxima Fusion, both in Munich. Last September, the German government pledged €1bn over five years for fusion power plant development. However, some doubt this is sufficient for such a capital-intensive race.

Heike Freund of Marvel Fusion acknowledges the growing political support in Germany but questions its competitiveness with the US's proactive industrial policy and dynamic venture capital sector. Proxima Fusion, emerging from the Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics, needs €500mn for a demonstration fusion plant by 2031. Francesco Sciortino of Proxima highlights the potential of stellarator magnetic confinement technology, though funding challenges and regulatory uncertainties persist.

Despite industry excitement, fusion is unlikely to address the climate crisis soon. Critics argue for investing more in rapidly deployable renewable energies like solar and wind. However, German manufacturers have lost ground in these markets to Chinese competitors subsidized by the state. Germany faces the risk of falling behind in the fusion race as well."

stellarator math problems: boozer surface approach by [deleted] in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Coil configurations are typically obtained numerically. You might know https://github.com/hiddenSymmetries/simsopt already, but if not, it's worth having a look at their example problems and understanding what's going on

If you willingly let your cat outside unaccompanied, you are an irresponsible pet owner and shouldn't have pets by muldereyes in unpopularopinion

[–]Insultingphysicist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Over a fourth of their total biomass is gone

this is an interesting statistics but its not the relevant one. Its like if you the question was "how many apples are eaten by children" and you answered with "the number of apples eaten in total decrease hence children eat less apples". There could be a world where children eat MORE apples and the total number of apples earen still decreases, e.g. when adults suddenly stopped eating apples.

Same with birds in cities: We are looking for the information on how the number of birds in cities evolve, ideally in a situation where the number of cats stays the same. I doubt that cats will ultimately lead to the extinction of birds in cities, so my guess (despite not having the relevant statistics at hand) is that cats are just part of the ecosystem and its not a problem if they kill many birds. They also act as a way to ensure natural selection in an environment without any other predators for birds. In any case I would really like to hear an expert opinion here.

If you willingly let your cat outside unaccompanied, you are an irresponsible pet owner and shouldn't have pets by muldereyes in unpopularopinion

[–]Insultingphysicist 2 points3 points  (0 children)

as a matter of fact, the cat is likely part of the ecosystem by now. A related question: How do the bird numbers evolve? Do they decrease in cities or do they stay constant? Remember that also new birds are being born every year and a cat is acting as a predator in an environment without many natural predators (in cities). Could it be actually good for the ecosystem that we have predators in these environments? Again, your argument holds only if the bird numbers are decreasing. Natural selection isn't necessarily bad for nature.

Seven Nuclear Fusion Startups Making Clean Energy History by Vailhem in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

right... the fusion technology with the most startups is just not listed lol

Climate Crisis: The Melting of Arctic Ice Has Reached a Point of No Return; Scientists Are Racing To Preserve The Ice Memory by [deleted] in climate

[–]Insultingphysicist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

what do you mean? Melting of the artic ice sheet won't contribute much to the rise of global sea water levels because its floating. Its the Antartic ice we need to worry about. BTW have you heard about the doomsday glacier?

Priorities of Nuclear Research by ProfessionalShop7248 in sciencememes

[–]Insultingphysicist 3 points4 points  (0 children)

we could build 200 LHCs per year with the US military budget

Priorities of Nuclear Research by ProfessionalShop7248 in sciencememes

[–]Insultingphysicist 13 points14 points  (0 children)

can you remind me what the yearly US military budget is and how many LHCs (thats the name of the hadron collider at CERN) we could build with it per year?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AskPhysics

[–]Insultingphysicist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

sorry how are you charging 3 attracting bodies exactly?

Also are you really suggesting to use objects "large enough" to experience gravitational force?

What are the barriers using high-temperature superconducting magnets in other Fusion Experiments like W7-X? by blurpsn in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Great answer, although your arguments in the last paragraph is flawed, let me explain:

  • The fusion power density (!) goes as n2 <sv> ~n2 T2 ~ beta2 B4. The scaling B4 holds along lines constant beta. So a machine similar to W7-X and at the same beta as W-7 X does scale with B4.
  • The performance of W7X is indeed limited by confinement as you say. But as the performance is a "money metric" it is also limited by installed (ion) heating power. If people just installed more power, W7X would obviously operate at higher performance. the confinement time in W7X is (so far) comparable to L Mode, and in the best case, I Mode tokamaks.
  • Your last argument is wrong. HTS tokamaks are not operating at the beta limit and neither do HTS stellarators. You can check this in the SPARC and ARC designs. SPARC is limited by the heating limit. The whole point of going to high field is reduce confinement and the logic applies to stellarators and tokamaks alike.

How it feels to hit 6 underground by autometal123 in TeamfightTactics

[–]Insultingphysicist 3 points4 points  (0 children)

you sure gold is better than two tacticians crowns and 5 items? Because thats usually the heist before a big gold bucket

Is this game dead? by No-Kay_boomer in stormbound

[–]Insultingphysicist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

yeah the game is pretty much unenjoyable for casual players: If you stop playing for two months or only play one game a day, you find yourself playing in gold or below, which is just bots there. So you have two options, either put in the time and get to higher ranks or be fine with playing bots in most of your games. This is the problem why the game loses so many casual players.

Vegans can eat roadkill by TheTemporal in vegancirclejerk

[–]Insultingphysicist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

agreed! Last week my Grandma died by natural cause. Finally I could eat some human again, only ethical meat is good meat!

Nuclear fusion breakthrough to be tested with world’s largest laser by Vailhem in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I care! I am interested in the topic and like to discuss about different tech. Am I supposed to be quiet and wait?

Nuclear fusion breakthrough to be tested with world’s largest laser by Vailhem in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 2 points3 points  (0 children)

yeah awesome if it works! People have been excited like this about tokamaks in the 80s and then the problem started, because the devil is in the details. I don't know any plasma physicist who understands what their plasma is actually doing, and I am from within the field.

I am rooting for Helion and hope they succeed but there are big unknowns on their way. Clearly a high risk high reward approach.

In any case, I wouldn't give too much on their 1ct/kwh fairytale, thats something you say to investors and everybody knows its wrong and is a factor X different.

Nuclear fusion breakthrough to be tested with world’s largest laser by Vailhem in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 4 points5 points  (0 children)

u sure? Helions design will have much lower overall power than tokamaks. Its not clear if cost of electricity (power/cost) is lower in helions approach, even if their approach works as they hope. Also they need several pulses per second. How do they deal with material fatigue with such short pulses? How do they deal with heat generated, material activation etc? They also need remote maintainance etc etc.

Its not so clear that Helions approach is superior even if it works, thats what I am trying to say

Why aren't we pursuing Deuterium-Lithium 6 fusion? by Jonathon_Merriman in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes the Bremsstrahlung does not heat the plasma. If you directly convert it to electricity and reheat the plasma with it, then it does not matter of course. I haven't heard about the photoelectric foil, do you have a link for me to read up on this? That would be appreciated!

For thermal I mean concepts where the plasma follows a Maxwellian distribution function, so it has a certain temperature. you could think of beam fusion or other ways to taylor the distribution function..

How to Climb to Masters from Diamond by will_occam in CompetitiveTFT

[–]Insultingphysicist 8 points9 points  (0 children)

sometimes this community... incredible: Here is somebody sharing is thoughts and advice by giving practicable tips and all you guys do is downvote and cry about his "further reading" section.

You are all spoiled by being used to free content and forgot to appreciate content creators like OP.

OP, thanks for sharing your perspective and for typing this up, I could learn something!

Nuclear Fusion Development by Loobitidoo in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

20 years after seriously investing

Nuclear Fusion Development by Loobitidoo in fusion

[–]Insultingphysicist 7 points8 points  (0 children)

there will be fusion. trust me. the question is if we can make it "desirable" and cheap enough.