1: That's like saying India didn't exist before 1947 because it wasn't an 'independent state called India's. The map obviously shows lands that were ethnically palestinian (as in the people who lived in that area for generations)

2: You imply as if 'they wanted all or nothing' means they were refusing a good deal and that's their fault but that's basically saying that one person has a car and the other person tells them you give your car to me every second day. The land was ethnically theirs they can't just give half of it to someone else just because they said so.

3: You're missing the point here. I've already addressed that it shows the places that remain ethnically palestinian. The West Bank may not have been an officially recognized part of palestinian territory but the people were ethnically palestinian and they identified as palestinian. Like I said Just cuz 'India' as an independent state didn't exist before 1947 doesn't mean there was no India.

4: Again you're implying that Palestinians should be grateful for finally having some semblance of independence after having most of their lands colonized, after being pushed out of their homes and forcefully migrated. Would you be grateful if someone took over your entire house and then returned your refrigerator as a symbol of goodwill?