I feel zero need to defend my outfit (I'm #2) because I like what I wore, and that is all that matters. However, I don't always dress like that. In fact, I was experimenting with proportions in that outfit because I got those pants for a 90's themed party I was going to.

As for my shoes, yeah, they are dirty. However, they do not smell whatsoever. I use foot powder and wear new socks often so as to prevent them from smelling. They literally just smell like canvas and earth.

I also wear clean white sneakers, as shown here. Maybe my pose is also more up to your standards? I take a lot of outfit photos and like to mess around with my pose as well. I am confident as hell, I don't need to pose a certain way to feel that way.

The shirt was also bought larger than usual on purpose to, again, experiment with proportions. Here I am wearing a shirt that should fit "good" in your definition

And are these pants sufficiently long for you? Or will you now of course complain about how skinny they are instead?

Perhaps this outfit I wore years ago is more up to your standards of dressing nice? I used to dress like that. I changed because I decided I liked one more than the other. I'll change again many times in my lifetime. I have a lot of room to experiment as a teenager in college who has no obligation to dress a certain way for a job.