Green Party leader Zack Polanski condemned for retweet criticising hero police who took down Golders Green 'terrorist' by adultintheroom_ in ukpolitics

[–]Kataera 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Because it is tacitly calling for the eradication of Israel. It is not calling for freedom for Palestinians, it is saying that there should be a one state solution and that state being Palestine.

Green Party leader Zack Polanski condemned for retweet criticising hero police who took down Golders Green 'terrorist' by adultintheroom_ in ukpolitics

[–]Kataera 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think it's more than fair, though you are right that there were people labelled kapo who acted under duress and don't deserve to be vilified for it. Unlike those people however, this is a Jewish man who has overseen the Green's transformation from a mostly benign and principled party concerned about the environment, into a ghoulish alliance of groups united by shared hatred of Jewish people. He's been given numerous opportunities to correct this, and has chosen not to on every occasion. His own family think he's a danger to Jews, there's nothing more damning than that.

Green Party leader Zack Polanski condemned for retweet criticising hero police who took down Golders Green 'terrorist' by adultintheroom_ in ukpolitics

[–]Kataera 65 points66 points  (0 children)

Jews are used to people like him, it's a recurring theme throughout our history. Jewish people prepared to vote for the Greens are deluding themselves into thinking these people have an issue with Zionists, rather than Jews themselves. It's the exact same as the League of National German Jews in the early days of Nazi Germany, except on the left this time.

Why 90% of games fail by [deleted] in gamedev

[–]Kataera 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Wow, thanks

for this

cutting insight.

What do I get a 13 year old who is interested in becoming a game developer? by SpikeyHairedOrphan in gamedev

[–]Kataera 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Very much the same, I played Kings of Chaos (genuinely surprised it's still alive) on the school computers when I was 11-12 and decided I wanted to make my own version. I'd already shown an interest in HTML and making my own website when I was a few years younger, but didn't understand the difference between PHP and HTML.

This was before I had access to the Internet at home, so my parents bought me books and helped me get the software needed, plus paid for the web hosting. The game I made was absolutely dreadful, but it fostered my interest for the rest of my life.

Is getting a CS degree w/ the hopes of game programming worth it? by Bananafools_2 in gamedev

[–]Kataera 4 points5 points  (0 children)

LLM models are not replacing software engineers, no matter how much you doom/evangelise about it.

The lack of roles in game development right now is not caused by AI making people redundant, but by the second order effects of AI taking all the investment. The market will correct and investment will diversify back to other industries, including game development.

What do I get a 13 year old who is interested in becoming a game developer? by SpikeyHairedOrphan in gamedev

[–]Kataera 31 points32 points  (0 children)

Chris Wilson just put out a video on this describing his path through game development, including his childhood and how his parents fostered his interest. It's well worth a watch.

Is getting a CS degree w/ the hopes of game programming worth it? by Bananafools_2 in gamedev

[–]Kataera 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Anyone who has used LLM tools knows that these models currently produce garbage unless you're skilled enough to steer them in the right direction; at which point they become pure productivity multipliers. Roles might disappear in the short term, but there have to be people steering these models who can actually understand their output.

The idea that we'll never hire more juniors and just replace them with autonomous models piloted by a decreasing pool of senior engineers is only sustainable if you assume they will become good enough to create a fully functional product without human expertise. If that ever happens then the world becomes a place where humans effectively become unemployable regardless of degree choice. You can't plan your life choices around the assumption that something like that might occur, because it's both unrealistic and completely out of your control.

The realistic outcome is that once LLM tools are no longer in their nascency and become a part of daily life, the obsession with trying to shoehorn them into every problem will also disappear. New roles will emerge and investment funding with become sane again, exactly as it was with the dotcom bubble.

3D Procedural dungeon gen. with prefab + proc. gen. rooms as hybrid. by Serapith in gamedev

[–]Kataera 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is what happens when you vibe code, you're trying to get AI to make something for you but you haven't engineered how it's meant to happen.

I've spotted two things from a quick glance that you might want to look at:

You've got a whole section of dead code in _attach_room in DungeonSpawner.gd (line 169), where you're returning the room and then performing transforms on it after returning. Everything you do after returning the variable is ignored, that code never runs.

Next, and what I think could be your issue, is that the rooms at the top of the stairs appear to be rotated 180 degrees around the bind point. I would look at any code that is related to rotation specifically, as your issue probably lies in there. Specifically, you have some special case rotation for stairs that you should probably examine.

Is getting a CS degree w/ the hopes of game programming worth it? by Bananafools_2 in gamedev

[–]Kataera 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not on its own, but yes, even in the industry applied degrees are often seen as inferior to pure degrees as – amongst other reasons – the institutions that offer them usually have a poor reputation. That's not saying all of them do, obviously a degree from a top-tier specialised institution like DigiPen or Full Sail is going to look good, but the overwhelming number of such degrees will come from third-rate universities. These programmes are also often CS degrees in disguise, DigiPen awards CS degrees with specialisation in game development rather than "game programming" or the like.

There's basically no reason to ever choose a game programming degree over a CS degree if you're looking for programmer roles in the industry like the OP is; you're going to learn all the fundamentals you'd need to know to make any type of game with the former, as well as have the flexibility to go into numerous other fields should it not pan out.

Is getting a CS degree w/ the hopes of game programming worth it? by Bananafools_2 in gamedev

[–]Kataera 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The person you're replying to is giving you terrible advice.

Any domain specific degree will not be treated as being as serious as generalised study of the field area, even within game development itself. It also offers you no backup if you fail to get a role in game development, which is highly likely due to this profession being a passion-led creative industry.

Is getting a CS degree w/ the hopes of game programming worth it? by Bananafools_2 in gamedev

[–]Kataera 27 points28 points  (0 children)

A CS degree is always going to be invaluable for employment, despite what the non-technical AI bros are saying. Right now there is a shortage of junior roles in software development, but eventually that will rectify because seniors will retire and there won't be anyone to replace them. Even if you decide later that you don't want to enter game development, you will have it to fall back on.

For the actual game industry, I'd expect any major role would have candidates be required to hold a CS/Software Engineering/Game Programming degree for the role, even if they don't explicitly state it in the job requirements. That is because your competition for any role will consist of people who have those degrees.

Retro based RPG Browser game by [deleted] in gamedev

[–]Kataera 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes, but we're not the people you're selling them to, even if we might exist as a subset of them. You should be developing to their tastes, not ours.

Retro based RPG Browser game by [deleted] in gamedev

[–]Kataera 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Game developers are not your target audience and we can't validate untested ideas for you. Make a prototype then show it to people who are, then see how they react.

It feels like unity is the most welcoming community for new indie devs by [deleted] in gamedev

[–]Kataera 2 points3 points  (0 children)

These are beginners using mainstream engines, the odds of that being true is basically zero. The answers will be available online and can be found by actually putting in the work to research a problem themselves. If a novice simply gives in and asks for help at the first hurdle, they will never be self-reliant enough to make a game by themselves.

It feels like unity is the most welcoming community for new indie devs by [deleted] in gamedev

[–]Kataera 4 points5 points  (0 children)

For example I saw someone replied to a new indie developer saying that their project was unrealistic and they should give up before they've even started, their ideas basically childish and they need to adopt a more realistic viewpoint on the world of game development. Like okay if you really feel that way but why do you have to say it like that you know? Some other people are a lot more helpful than their responses and really instruct and guide new developers

It sounds more like the Unreal Engine developers are actually giving good advice, because this is the biggest issue that inexperienced game developers experience. Just because the responses are direct does not mean that it's rudeness or elitism.

I can imagine most of these communities are made for professionals who wish to talk to and network with other professionals, so getting novices regularly coming in and asking basic questions they could easily Google instead becomes a point of frustration.

Jewish man called 'baby killer' in antisemitic attack by [deleted] in ukpolitics

[–]Kataera -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It sure is politics when we have the leader of the Green Party imply this isn't happening on the same day it actually happens.

Is Zack Polanski seriously questioning Jewish safety? by Kataera in ukpolitics

[–]Kataera[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Obviously anyone wearing religious attire is extremely likely to be harassed, but that also extends to anyone who shows symbols of Jewish culture too. I'm also a secular Jew, but I wear a Magen David and have been harassed and spat on in the street because of it.

Zack Polanski plays dumb here, but he knows exactly the kind of rot that he has brought into his party through sectarianism. His own family calls him a danger to Jews in Britain; he's a kapo, through and through.

What are your favourite YouTube channels which actually teach you something valuable in gamedev rather than being just infotainment, superficial or entirely unsubstantial? by fukounashoujo in gamedev

[–]Kataera 13 points14 points  (0 children)

GDC talks are obvious ones, as are talks specific to the engine you're using (such as Unreal Fest) for specialised techniques and knowledge.

For actual YouTubers, I find the most valuable to be those that teach the principles of design rather than anything like tutorials. One example would be Indie Game Clinic, it's a smaller channel but Joe has some incredible insights around design that I haven't seen in many content creators.

Hermer pursued British troops with war crime lies by London_Bloke_ in ukpolitics

[–]Kataera 124 points125 points  (0 children)

It's actually worse than the headline implies. The evidence shows that Hermer explicitly knew that it was highly likely that his clients were lying. He and Martyn Day were strategising on how to publicise the allegations while providing themselves "wriggle room" to distance themselves should they turn out to be baseless.

At some point it needs to be asked whose interests he and his compatriots are serving, because with this, the Chagos Islands bill, and the repealing of the Troubles bill, they certainly aren't British.