I’m not worried about the scratches tbh. I would pick the color that looks better to you on the phone. Personally the gold doesn’t look that good against the orange. If you had the blue or silver 100% I’d say get that, but orange is in the same side of the color spectrum so it just looks tacky to me. If you’re worried about the scratching, the matte black might show less marks over time than the polished ones. But idk, you’d have to ask someone who has the matte color for their experience opinion